Welcome to you all in my blog NEPALI IDEA. This is my personal blog. All ideas do not necessarily reflect and represent my other positions. -Khimlal Devkota, Faculty, ICMS, Ph.D. Scholar, Constituent Assembly Member/Senior Advocate, Board of Directors, National Legislative Academy.
Thursday, February 23, 2012
Sunday, February 5, 2012
Tuesday, January 10, 2012
Saturday, January 7, 2012
Wednesday, January 4, 2012
Sunday, December 11, 2011
Maoist Movement of Nepal:Development of Tactics and Strategies Legal and Political Aspects
Maoist Movement of Nepal:Development of Tactics and Strategies
Legal and Political Aspects
By
Attorney/CA Member
KHIMLAL DEVKOTA
SUBMITTED TO
KYOTO UNIVERSITY,JAPAN
3rd Dec 2011
contents
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 2
Part One 3
1 INTRODUCTION 3
1.1 General introduction 3
Part Two 3
2 THEORITICAL DEVELOPMENT 3
2.1 Historical facts about revolution: 3
2.2 Reassessment of Nepali history 4
2.3 Establishment of Objectives 5
Part Three 5
3 IMPLEMENTATION 5
3.1 Class analysis: force of the revolution 6
3.2 Findings of analysis: possible problems 6
3.3 Series of tactics envisioned 6
3.4 Development of MLM: Nepal's specific as "Prachandapath" 7
3.5 Development of democracy in 21st century 7
Part Four 8
4 PRACTICAL DEVELOPMENT OF MLM IN NEPALI CONTEXT 8
4.1 Chunbang meeting: major event 9
4.2 Kamidanda meeting: major event 9
4.3 Balaju -Kharipati-Palungtar and Parisdanda: 9
Part Five 10
5 TACTICAL FLEXIBILITY AND STRATEGIC RIGIDITY 10
5.1 Tactics and strategies 10
Part Six 12
6 MAJOR ACHIEVEMENTS 12
Part Seven 12
7 Political development and constitution writing process 12
8 CONCLUSION 13
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Nepal, country with full of diversity in terms of geography, culture, economy, religion, ethnicity social characters and structures and several others, is fertile for creating revolutionary environment. On this backdrop, various political movements have engaged us of which a decade long people's war is the most prominent of all. The first part of the paper deals with general background of the character of the Nepalese society that was fertile for fueling the various political and revolutionary movements.
Second part deals with theoretical aspect of the Maoist movement in Nepal, theoretical development on the basis of historical fact, reassessment of historical development, understanding of ground reality of Nepalese society to begin the people's movement and the detailed analysis of the characteristics of Nepalese society and envisioning the pragmatic path to make it compatible with Marxism in contemporary situation. Concrete analysis of concrete situation is a maxim is trying to apply in Nepali context.
Part three is focused on theoretical development of MLM in Nepalese context and its implementation. Pragmatic approach of the MLM in Nepal and its maneuver to explain class analysis based on the finding of problems on strategy and tactics adopted by Russian model of revolution or Chinese model and model of democracy in 21st century are embodied in this section.
Fourth part of the paper explains the practical development of Marxism in Nepal context with some popularly known events such as Chunbang meeting, Balaju, Kharipati, Palungtar plenum and Perisdanda meeting.
The fifth part of the paper provides better insight on the experience of tactical flexibility and strategic rigidity and its relevance to the Maoist's movement in Nepal based on my experience. It also highlights our historical responsibility, Marxism, imperialism and the rising of the middle class of 21st century.
Part six is focused on major achievement of the Maoist movement such as declaration of republic, election of CA, inclusiveness, federalism, secularism etc. Part seven highlights the present political condition legal aspects of constitution writing and its linkage to the combatant management. Finally the conclusion which provides the plausible explanation behind the achievements of the Maoist movement in Nepal; and recent political and legal development. It emphasizes on the pragmatic approach with the up to date analysis of the national and international milieu is the first and foremost factor for the uprising of any political movement and for the socio-economic transformation.
Part One
1 INTRODUCTION
1.1 General introduction
Nepal is a landlocked country, which is surrounded from three sides by the expansionist India and in the north surrounded by the reformist China. It has diverse geographical terrain along with diversity in culture, ethnicity, language and climate. A large section of the Nepalese people is spread in different countries for employment, mainly in India for army and other kinds of jobs.
In Nepal, a centralized reactionary state equipped with a modern, powerful and lavish army and a bureaucracy with centralized governing system has been in existence. The economic and resource distribution has been uneven. Nepal is predominantly rural and the exploited peasants, who represent 90% of the total population, are spread in these villages. Centuries of poverty and inequality, social and political exclusion, gender, caste and ethnic based discrimination, skewed distribution of the resources of production, and corruption and bad governance were the primary characteristics of the then Nepalese society. The unwillingness of the state to invest in infrastructure, such as roads, schools, hospitals, electricity, drinking water and irrigation exacerbated social exclusion and structurally embedded poverty. Spatial disparities caused feelings of injustice. These features of the then Nepalese society were predominant in remote areas of Mid-Western and Far-Western Development Regions. Thus the socio-economic condition, geographical isolation, poor governance, centralized governing system, ideological contention, disproportionate allocation of the resources, skewed distribution of resources, historical legacy, development of international strategy on socio-economic and military aspects, conflicting interests of international actors, royal coup and development of national politics etc. fuelled the revolutionary movement.
Part Two
2 THEORITICAL DEVELOPMENT
2.1 Historical facts about revolution:
History of the Nepalese communist party dates back to half a century but those initiatives were without any tangible achievements. Nepali Congress adopted the armed struggle in pursuit of democracy against the tyranny of Rana regime at the time when the spawning communist movements were not in their capacity to adopt it. Later on, the communist movement has taken various forms and essences with the popular support. However the fledging communist movements were mired by intra party struggle, rifts and division and this has became the characteristic of the communist parties. The time period of around 1950's Jhapa Revolt, 1972, 1980's and 90's movements were led by communist parties but most of them were mass-movements not related with communist movement. Communist parties were limited to reading, writing, publishing statements, division and counter and encounter each other. So, without proper reassessment of the situation another revolution was out of imagination.
2.2 Reassessment of Nepali history
In order to develop the tactics for the people's revolt, the party reassessed the history and its legacy. Through the reassessment the party identified the following facts about the Nepali history
A. The analysis of the reactionaries that the king and monarch are deep-rooted in the Nepalese society is not true. The tradition of the Nepalese society has not been monarchist but democratic and autonomy-oriented.
B. The shameful defeat in the war with British-India and nature of the treaty signed indicate the contradiction and alliance of feudalism and imperialism and led Nepal to semi-colonial state. But this treaty however exposed the national capitalist character of feudal ruling classes and thus nurtured the development of patriotic and national feeling of modern sense amongst the people.
C. Needs to lay the foundation of a consolidated national unity on the basis of equality and freedom in accordance with the right of nations to self-determination for the new democratic revolution was assessed.
D. Observing the fall of Rana Regime it was reassessed that the Party should always make efforts and struggle to be flexible with due consideration to the fluidity of other political groups and to protect itself from its influence.
E. The major subjective factor behind the failure in making due political advancement even after the continuous struggle of the Nepalese people since around 1950 and their dedication, devotion and sacrifices displayed in them, is nothing but the reformism and revisionism dominant in the Nepalese communist movement.
As a result of reassessment of the history of Nepali society, governance and political movements, following realities were recognized.
o Nepal was recognized as a semi-feudal & semi-colonial country reeling under the double exploitation & oppression of feudalism & imperialism with large proportion of population (more than 91%) constitutes of the pauperized, landless, and poor and lower class peasants scattered over the vast rural areas.
o The skewed socio-economic condition and lack of political consciousness among the general public, qualitative and quantitative weakness of the modern working class due to underdevelopment of the industries in the cities leveraged the power of the enemies that are centralized in the city. And the enemies are much more powerful as compared to that of the revolutionaries.
o According to the experiences of class struggle in the era of imperialism, it is possible to develop a militant & revolutionary Party, new culture & revolutionary people’s movement and to bring about radical change in society only by moving ahead along the path of People’s War from the very beginning.
o It was finally recognized that to lead revolution is to lead the people's war.
In conclusion, it was found that
• Even general reforms taken as a byproduct of violent and illegal struggle. The reactionary propaganda that the Nepalese people are peace loving and that they don’t like violence is absolutely false.
• Nepali peoples are great warrior of the world. In national context, from the year 1951 onwards, mainly the Nepalese peasants and other sections of the people have been joining in countless number of violent & armed conflicts against the reactionary state and the anti-establishment feelings among the Nepalese people has been very strong.
• Finally it was concluded that fighting against imperialist, feudal forces and the reactionaries is greatest responsibility of the New Democratic Revolution because the revisionist elements have been time & again ditching & conspiring against the fighting tendency of the Nepalese people.
2.3 Establishment of Objectives
To attain the goal of establishing a New Democratic republic the following policies were formulated:
1. To oppose the monarchical parliamentary multi-party system and to accelerate propagandist agitation in favor of the New Democratic system.
2. To build a revolutionary, militant and new type of Communist Party.
3. To build a revolutionary united Front as an instrument of struggle and an embryo of the new power.
4. To lay emphasis on the preparations of people’s war.
5. To develop a patriotic and democratic movement against feudalism, imperialism and Indian expansionism.
6. To accelerate rural class struggle centering on the slogan of land to the tiller and to concentrate main force on the same.
7. To develop class and mass organizations, to establish Party leadership over them and to develop people’s movement in favor of their problems.
8. To pay special attention to expand the Party to lower classes, oppressed ethnic groups, tribes and depressed castes and to the rural and remote areas.
9. To accord priority to the illegal works and works in the rural areas, to develop as secondary activities the legal and urban works and coordinate the two spheres of activities.
10. To support national liberation, New Democratic and socialist movements all over the world, to emphasize on proletarian internationalism and to develop relations and contacts with the fraternal parties and organizations the world over.
11. To oppose & expose all forms of revisionism.
12. To propagate Marxism-Leninism-Maoism in a systematic manner.
Part Three
3 IMPLEMENTATION
3.1 Class analysis: force of the revolution
For the implementation of the New Democratic Revolution, the Nepali Society was analyzed and classified into the following categories based on their possible contribution and attitude towards the new Democratic Revolution. It was believed that the categorization could be beneficial for the development of the tactics and strategies for the advancement of the revolution. These major motivating forces identified for the New Democratic Revolution were:
• The Proletariat,
• The Farm Workers,
• Middle Peasants,
• Rich Peasants,
• Petty - Bourgeois Class and
• National Bourgeoisie.
3.2 Findings of analysis: possible problems
In the present era of imperialism & proletarian revolution, the enemy class is practicing various forms of conspiratorial strategies to stop revolution in countries like ours. Amongst them we must focus our attention on the following, because we can’t arrive at a correct strategy without understanding the strategy of the enemy. The major advantages that the enemy class has over the revolutionary class are:
1. Monopolistic hold over the communication over the whole world at this time can help the enemy to launch a disinformation campaign with deliberate propaganda about ‘terrorism’, ‘fall of socialism’ and the superiority and success of capitalism and is attempting to lower the morale of the people through the strategy of psychological warfare.
2. All the imperialist forces and the reactionary ruling classes of each country are campaigning strategically by spreading the network of well trained and technically equipped spies.
3. Inventing new forms of reforms & democracy in order to confuse the people politically.
4. Establishment of the networks of NGOs and INGOs have been spread in order to engage some educated middle class people, to prevent them from falling below the middle class and to entrap the people in the petty reformist mirage.
5. Encouraged unemployed youths to get scattered all over the world and to wander in India in the name of employment.
6. Polluting the minds of the people through propagation of religion and other means after entering into rural areas with attractive slogans.
3.3 Series of tactics envisioned
In our situation, the armed struggle can be initiated, sustained and developed only through a skillful implementation of a policy which would go like this:
• Give priority to the rural work, but do not leave out the urban work;
• Give priority to illegal struggle, but do not leave out the legal struggle, too;
• Give priority to specific strategic areas, but do not leave out work related to the mass movement, too;
• Give priority to class struggle in rural areas, but do not leave out countrywide struggle, too;
• Give priority to guerrilla actions, but do not leave out political exposure & propaganda, too;
• Give priority to propaganda work within the country but do not leave out worldwide propaganda, too;
• Give priority to build army organization, but do not leave out to build front organizations, too;
• Give priority to relying on one’s own organization and force, but do not miss to forge unity- in- action, to take support & help from international arena.
The successful development of People’s War in Nepal will be governed by decentralized actions based on central policy, by launching actions at different isolated spots of the enemy and by applying large force against small forces in order to get quick victory, by adopting hit & run tactics, by promoting guerrilla actions under the centralized plan from different parts of the country but by giving special attention to specific strategic areas, and as Mao has said, by organizing and mobilizing as many people as possible and as fast as possible and with as good a method as possible while placing the question of capturing political power at the centre.
3.4 Development of MLM: Nepal's specific as "Prachandapath"
The founding of new unity on a new basis laid a concrete ideological and organizational ground for conducting “Rectification Campaign” as directed by the Fourth Extended Meeting of the Central Committee. The same meeting worked out the Fifth Plan for the PW. The Fifth Plan period which had succeeded in lifting the whole People’s War to a new height of development occupies an important place in our Party history for the following reasons-
1. In the very beginning of this plan implementation, death of alternative Politburo Member Com. Suresh Wagle (Basu) established the great martyrdom, high records of sacrifice, intensified the resentment of the masses against the enemies all over the country and established the revolutionary image of the Party among the people.
2. “Rectification Campaign” was conducted by the Central Committee in the middle of the fifth plan strengthened ideological and emotional unity of the Party; and developed substantially the ideological level and efficiency of the Party to fight against the opportunism.
3. During this plan period, qualitatively high-level military successes were achieved in all regions in general and the Western region in particular.
4. At the final stage of this period, all mysteries and characteristics of the Alok trend appearing as ‘left’ liquidations were exposed through strenuous and incessant efforts of Com. Prachanda and others. Indeed, the exposure and synthesis of the Alok trend is a great success of "Rectification Campaign". In essence, this is yet another triumph of the proletarian line led by Com. Prachanda.
3.5 Development of democracy in 21st century
The main essence of the teachings of Marxism-Leninism-Maoism is to advance ahead through continuous revolution by scientifically synthesizing world proletarian movement enriched by the great experiences of revolution and counter-revolution. In giving leadership to the democratic revolution against feudalism and imperialism in Nepal, our Party has been from the very beginning laying emphasis on applying the teachings of MLM, not in the form of dogma but in the form of creative application and development as a “guide to action”. In this great process of applying and developing the teachings of MLM based on the concrete condition of the Nepalese revolution, we have been waging continuous struggle against rightist revisionists as well as the dogmata-revisionists. The Party has already synthesized the discovery at “Prachanda-Path” as a special chain of ideas in the Nepalese revolution based on this development process of class struggle and ideological struggle.
On the basis of experience of history, analysis of present world situation and five years’ enriched experiences of the Nepalese People’s war, the Party’s second historic Conference has made many important political and military syntheses.
The Party
Revolutionary party for 21st century need to be developed into an organizational theory, methodology and system so that they can stop counter-revolution and this is valid even today. This is the problem of application and development of the theory of two-line struggle within the Party and continuous revolution under the dictatorship of the proletariat.
The Army
The experience of revolution and counter-revolution in the 20th Century has clearly shown that if the proletarian class advances ahead with correct revolutionary ideology, policy and programmed then the people can develop from almost zero to the level of an invincible people’s army which can reduce to dust the ultramodern and powerful army of the enemy. But if wrong ideology prevails then the same army can become a weapon of counter-revolution.
The State
Though capture of state power through people’ war under the leadership of the Party of the proletariat was the main theme of the revolution, the experience of 20th century has clearly proved that the question of continuous democratization of the state power is thousand times more difficult and complex than capturing state power. In Nepalese context we have been talking about the liberation of the masses from class, national, regional, and gender oppression; national and regional autonomy along with the rights to self-determination; party freedom for anti-feudal and anti-imperialist forces. In this situation it should be stressed on correctly organizing the right to self-determination of the masses for the continuous democratization of the state.
Thus, only through the appropriate development of the Party, Army and State as stated above that democracy in the twenty-first century would enhance the process of continuous revolution and counter-revolution.
Part Four
4 PRACTICAL DEVELOPMENT OF MLM IN NEPALI CONTEXT
4.1 Chunbang meeting: major event
• Questions of Leadership
• Correct handling of the contradiction or inners struggle
• Tactical swift to focused village to urban
• Alliance with parliamentary political parties against autocratic Monarchy
• Democratic republican
• Proper balance on Nationality and Democracy
• Rectification-self criticism new type of party building
4.2 Kamidanda meeting: major event
• Seize fire agreement
• CPA, AAMA, Interim Constitution
• Tactics series: people’s war, people’s movement; negotiation and diplomatic initiation.
• Joining Interim Government
• Election of CA:
• Formation of government: Under the Leadership of Maoist Party
With deciding election of CA agreement was signed for formation of interim government including Maoist party. After a decade long people’s war Maoist representative became a part of government. Government had fixed their common minimum programmed. Main focus was; socio-economic transformation, constitution writing, integration and rehabilitation of PLA, and democratization of NA.
4.3 Balaju -Kharipati-Palungtar and Parisdanda:
Before CA election, the extended meetings of Balaju was convened and was the first meeting after seize fire. Division was for CA election or different type of revolution backtracking from peace process. Chitwan meeting was held after promulgation of interim constitution and the entire parliament member were participated there with new coat. Then division became between coat and without coat.
Kharipati meeting was held at a time party itself was leading the government with majore portfolio. Again debate was leading the government by top leadership is a kind of give-up revolution. Peace and constitution is a reformist line so line and leadership both became reformist so it is needed to coming back from the government and preparation for revolt. But plan of revolt was not fixed and finalized.
Palungtar plenum was a three line debate. Again it is focused on peace and constitution or people’s revolt. Finally it was undecided extended meeting more than 6 thousand leaders and cadres were gathered there. It was trying to pass the line of people’s revolt without any preparation but finally it was corrected by perisdanda meeting peace and constitution is appropriate line for this moment.
Part Five
5 TACTICAL FLEXIBILITY AND STRATEGIC RIGIDITY
When the Maoists movement was just spawning in Nepal, people used to think Maoists woodenheaded. At the end of the 20th century, when the communist regimes all over the world were dismantling and in Nepal, where multiparty democracy with constitutional monarchy was just established putting down the three decades long authoritarian panchayat regime of the then monarch, the advocating of the armed movement by the Maoists instead of institutionalizing the achievements so far, displeased some people. Thus started Maoists movement, with unfavorable situations inside and outside the territory, in about a decade became the largest party of the country. The demand of the Constituent Assembly dating 60 years back became possible, the two and half centuries old monarchial system came to an end establishing republic and for the pioneer restructuring of the state, constitutional commitment was made to establish federal states ending the unitary state system of ruling. Revolution established the agendas and now these agendas are molting to work on field, their usefulness is being tested. At the end, what the crux of the achievements was has a single answer; flexibility in tactics rigidity in strategy.
5.1 Tactics and strategies
1. Protracted people's war or urban insurrection: The party attempted to manage the new approaches of preparations for New Democratic Revolution. It assimilated that the Nepalese revolution would success neither in the Chinese way nor in the Russian way, but in its own unique style and thus was the achievements possible in such a short period of time. In a document of a meeting after a month of initiation of the war consciously speaks; in the current socioeconomic structure and the development of class struggle, armed struggle is not the appropriate means of capturing the central state power. The formation of human rights organization, making the mechanism of the civil society, journalists and advocates were the subjects of tactical flexibilities.
2. Questions of Leadership: Marxist leaders failed to develop their own successors and the whole movement was negatively affected by the end of the leader. Recognizing the historical fact, the tactic of collective leadership was opted. Leadership is not a nominee, it is grooming up from the revolution was the major tactical development regarding the leadership.
3. Dichotomizing the Society: Exposure of social problems existing in the society after the 1990 political change greatly helped the party to mobilize the people behind their cause by dichotomizing and polarizing the society by the identities such as, 'oppressed-oppressor', 'ruler-ruled', 'poor-rich', 'landlord-landless', and 'patriot-non patriot'. In this way they deepened (and created new) political, social, cultural and economic cleavages. These dichotomies fuelled the already developed feelings of injustice and frustration in the Nepalese people and thus garnered public support.
4. Military Operations: The people's war proceeded with continuous military attacks. In time, though it used to change its tactics by talks, war and so on, in continuous military attacks its territories could be seen vividly. Hindering the recruitment of the army, obstructing the runaway of the army was carried out after the inability to capture an army camp of one company even a preparation of 14 months.
5. Declaration of Base Area: Party concluded to develop base areas not in isolation but in core and periphery based. The areas were categorized as main area, secondary area for propaganda and enemy area.
6. Simultaneously War and Peace: It is possible to launch war and peace at a time. In the field battles are going on and at a top negotiation also going on not only in political level but also possible in military level too.
7. Strategic balance of power: Another specific character of the war is to maintain proper balance with national and international forces and targeting the principal enemy while joining hands with secondary enemies. National forces were divided in two parts for and against as a same manner international forces too.
8. Parallel state power: During the period of armed conflict various state structures such as court system, revenue collection mechanisms, own military and administrative structures were established; and the party asked for International community's including UN for the recognition of those state strucures.
9. Tactical swift: Hindering the recruitment process of the army by threatening the aspirants, calling the army out of the barracks and attacking, making false attacks and drawing the attention of the army away from the attacking points, ambushing the armed force heading to back the ones in the ongoing attack, supply side intervention for various basic needs, etc. were the examples of tactical swift.
10. Rural to Urban Strategy: The formation of human rights organization, making the mechanism of the civil society, journalists and advocates tight and fix may seem confronting and may be said eerie rightist; those were the subjects of tactical flexibilities. On one hand the party is talking of raising arms but on the other hand forms network of human rights organizations, creation of the situation of dilemma was also the tactic of the movement.
11. Agenda for negotiation: CA, Removal of Monarchy, Federalization of state, Inclusion and proportional representation with special rights for dalit and women, feudalism to capitalism move, continuation of revolution and completion of rest task of the revolution.
• The tactic adopted during the mid period of the people's war was round table conference, interim government and the election of the constituent assembly. Seeming extreme rightist; there was no way these slogans suit a revolutionary leftist party but the result of these became a subject to tie the hands of the reactionary forces. The slogan "let's institutionalize republic", after the royal massacre; where there was no smell of the People's Republic; seeming like extreme reformist, prepared a base for the party to achieve the republic. The party that had conducted the people's war with the slogan "let's leap forwards in the path of the people's war in order to establish people's state power" headed forwards saying Constituent assembly, democratic republic, and interim constitution, election of the constituent assembly.
12. Leadership of the government after the election: there was no absolute majority to the party after the election but the leading of the government was decided and executed.
13. Resignation, illegitimate step of the president: while discussing about accomplishment of Nepalese revolution, all of sudden the chapter about chief of the army came into play and quitted from the government by resigning. After a yearlong of street protest, again from the candidacy of prime minister till now, all these events verify tactical flexibility.
The above outlined events are the examples of tactical flexibility adopted by a revolutionary communist party. The more we become flexible in tactics, the more it helps us to become rigid in strategies. If we become rigid in tactics, then we have to be flexible in strategies, and when strategies flexibility is adopted, then there arises a question in idea, policy and principle.
Part Six
6 MAJOR ACHIEVEMENTS
Marx propounded theory; Lenin implemented in Russia as an insurrection; Mao did in China as a protracted people’s war. In Nepal we decided to develop MLM and fusion of both. The tangible achievements of the People's war can be presented in nutshell as:
• Interim Constitution
• Establishment of Republic
• Election of Constituent Assembly
• Inclusiveness in every sector of society
• Proportionate Representation
• Federal structure of the state
• Modality for integration and rehabilitation of the PLA.
Part Seven
7 POLITICAL DEVELOPMENT AND CONSTITUTION WRITING PROCESS
7.1 Our responsibility of changing time:
We are talking about the revolution in the first decade of the 21st century. Our chief responsibility is to develop forthcoming tactics keeping in mind about the characteristics of globalized imperialism, characteristics of the classes and the success and failure of revolutionary movements. We have considered that the base of our acceptance of multiparty competition is the downfall of communist regimes in the 20th century. Also we have to review the fundamental changes in the nature of revolutionary movements, imperialistic character and reactionary class in the first decade of the 21st century based on the deployment of communist regimes of the 20th century. Any discussion of ideas sans this type of review will turn fruitless.
7.2 Imperialism of the 21st century
Imperialism itself is in the changed state. To self sustain, it is in its continuous motion, and with the changed circumstances it is trying its best to modify itself. Being so, the power in chief contradiction with the oppressed nations in on timely change, and if the oppressed nations and classes failed to endorse tactics accordingly, then there is no other alternative than defeat. So, not to be defeated, it is necessary to discuss about today's imperialism and develop today's Marxism putting aside insistence.
Today's imperialism is not in the state of turning mutual contradictions into world war. The situation is of dividing mutual differences according to their interest, power and capability and the nature of such division is not in the state of maintaining colony by dividing traditional geography. Despite this, the imperialistic forces are heading forwards establishing multinational companies and organizations and retaining world management through mutual coordination. The imperialistic interest of this time is to expand its market and to capture the world through that expanded market. For this, they don’t think it necessary to capture a fixed geography.
Imperialism of this stage is in the character of its change from industrial capital to financial capital. Industrial capital is at least extended to investor, workers, manager and production and market that are why the state of supremacy of imperialism only or capital only cannot prevail. It has to maintain its mutual consonance with other parties too. But today, after the change of industrial capital to financial capital, the absolute capital and the absolute imperialistic power, in its solo decision, is in the state of mobilizing that capital. Imperialism uses to accomplish its work through its agents instead of working itself. It such condition, the Marxist methods and norms of the 20th century are insufficient, their development is essential. Ignoring the evolved character of the imperialism, if we managed to define imperialism in the obsolete ways and develop future tactics, there is not a single alternative to defeat.
7.3 Rising of the middle class in the 21st century
The size of classes and their character is changed in this time. There is a rapid rise of the middle class while running in the first decade of the 21st century. The proletariat class and the reactionary class are at decrement and the middle class is making up the maximum. During the middle of the 20th century, the middle class was minimal and any class could ensure victory by its help but now the middle class staying in the middle and those who adopt the tactic that can influence the middle class can achieve victory. In the 20th century, the middle class was unsteady and used to hover sometimes here and sometimes there but now it has become permanent. Based on size and number also this class is in the stage of being determining class. It is necessary to care about this fact.
Additionally, the 1990 political change provided the space to reflect on these problems. Freedom of expression and organization allowed people to pursue a radical agenda, previously not tolerated by the state. Democracy created opportunities for marginalized people to organize themselves to fight for their rights, while at the same time raising the expectations of the people. Politicians in the early 1990's fuelled these expectations to win the popular vote, but, once in power; they failed to address people's concerns. This greatly helped the CPN (M) to mobilize the people behind their cause. The CPN (M) was also very successful at polarizing people into for and against by dichotomizing identities such as 'oppressed-oppressor', 'ruler-ruled', 'poor-rich', 'landlord-landless', and 'patriot-non patriot'. In this way they deepened (and created new) political, social, cultural and economic cleavages. These dichotomies fuelled the already developed feelings of injustice and frustration in the Nepalese people.
7.4 Reality in changing context:
Practically we are talking about writing constitution based on above mentioned particular situation and changing context of the world society. We have a firm believe on Marxism is a concrete analysis of concrete condition. So we have to think about it. Constitution and communism is hard to matching. it is because for communist why it is needed constitution and law. Goal of the communist is Communism and which is, itself is a classless stateless and lawless such type of ideal society. so we can come in conclusion that there is no need of any kind of law and constitution in the stage of communism.
According to Marxist view law is a tools of exploitation it can be used for suppression of the enemy class of people. Class divided society law is used for control and creating a barrier of the changing interest of the people.
Classical Marxism is no more working in 21st century it is firm believer of the Maoist party. This is a key of the Maoist movement . Marxism is not a lifeless dogma it is need to change and update and develop with compatible changing context.
With above mentioned scenario Maoist movement raised a issue of new constitution through elected body as a constituent assembly. First it was started during war by peoples republican constitution. Peoples legal code peoples power and court rules and regulation.
During negotiation time minimum content of the constitution had publicized.
During interim constitution drafting period it has been submitted very comprehensive constitution draft to the interim constitution drafting committee.
After two years of constitution writing has been published next constitution draft based on constituent assembly debate.
Now it is in final phase of constitution drafting. These are the constitutional development of Maoist party itself.
Marxism do believe on result if result is fine doesn’t matter about process but formal democracy always confine within process rather than result it is main contradiction.
Second contradiction is political slogan based politics and materialized in content is very different. Everything need to making new is a slogan but what it is nobody knows. This is another irony.
Along with fundamental principles based confusion and barriers now we are in the final phase of constitution drafting. Presently Nepal is facing two main challenges. Of them, the first is to complete the peace process, which would require a resolution and implementation of the difficult issue of how to integration of the former Maoist combatants into national security forces and reintegration of the combatants into the society. The second key challenge is completing the drafting of a constitution with federal structure, preferential right to self determination and special rights for women and dalits. These issues are the bone of contentions among the major political parties. The political parties are utilizing these agendas to secure their position during the transitional politics. Though these two processes are interlinked with each other, the political parties have different perception regarding this.
Marxism always believes that everything is determined by politics. So it is often said, "Politics in command". However, law and constitution are tools of governance. We cannot imagine a territory without law. In this context, UCPN (M) has had practiced the constitution writing process at the time of peoples war. At the time of negotiation only a part of the content was publicized. Interim constitution drafting time it was hard negotiation about the issues of people's rights and political issues raised by the Maoist party at the time of peoples war such a forward-looking change, state restructuring, proportional representations, inclusion and others. Based on interim constitution party started to draft its own constitution for the peoples and party cadres and leaders too. Party decided to form a constitution drafting committee for the party purposes but it was so difficult to resolve the contrasting issues because we are not in the phase of complete revolution. When we based on debatable issues and settled issues in constituent assembly then draft is going to be a normal it is not serving a spirit of peoples war completely and if we based on the constitution draft of the peoples war time then it will not be accepted in Constitutional Assembly. Compromise is the most essential factor for all the political parties.
Through the peace and constitution writing processes, the UCPN (Maoist) is dynamically working to institutionalize a people’s governing system, a new political system and people’s federal republic where there will be inclusive and proportional representation and participation of the Nepalese people. But the situation within this largest party is not easy as it seems to be. The intraparty rift is deepening within the party regarding the conclusion of the peace process and the constitution writing. Expressing dissent against the final effort to ensure people’s right through peace and constitution, a faction within the Maoists is trying to end all the achievements concealing under revolutionary veil. Stepping outside the disciplinary boundary of revolutionaries and making mockery of the principles of a communist party, they are raising debate of no use for namesake.
The old ruler, especially the Nepali Congress who fears the existence, is standing against these changes and the CPN (UML) is hovering around the NC's position. The fear of existence is further fuelled by the intra party rift in all the major political parties. In a shameful effort, old rulers are ignoring the agreements of the CPA.
The major debates in the Constituent Assembly are:
Different understanding of Rules of law, democracy, independence of judiciary, separation of power etc. terms monopolized by the traditional political parties are hard to accept and adopt by the party arising through the New Democratic Revolution. Even most of the leaders are not familiar with the terms of the constitution some of the words are already became monopoly of it.
People's war was conducted with the overwhelming support of the society. Furthermore, the New Democratic Revolution has inculcated in public that everything should be new. But it would be possible only if the revolution was complete. But party is in the state of compromise. Compromise by all the political parties is the reality of the present day situation, but intention is the constitution with revolutionary spirit. Question arises, how we can balance it?
Another most important aspect of the Nepalese contemporary politics is that focus of the politics is always in slogan rather than technical details. Political interest cannot serve only by slogan. For the purpose of the fulfillment of the political interest need to have technical details. Gap between political slogan and technical details must be fulfilled by the proper balance between the two for the tangible outcome of the peace process.
Whatever disagreement there may be, in recent days all the major leaders of the major political parties are harping the slogan of agreement and this has inculcated the ray of hope in all Nepali people and the international community.
8 CONCLUSION
Political stand based on classical Marxism and writing constitution in 21st century is quite contrast. Constitution at present is matter of fact and classical Marxism is a philosophy. Philosophy materialization in constitution of 21st century is not a easy job.
Even though, Finally Maoist party has taken historical initiation for the liberation of the people. For this purpose it has developed its own clear objectives; it has developed its own style and methods. It has been highly appreciated by the other communist parties. The path taken by the Maoist party in Nepal is a new and unique to its soil. It doesn’t match with any practices of Marxism as it is a redefined mode so orthodox types of communist parties regard it as a reformist. Whether the movement is reformist or revolutionary let the future to judge it.
The plausible explanation behind the achievements of the People's war in nutshell are; strong leadership capability, initial brushing off of the grievances as the unrealistic ambition by the state authorities, modality adopted of local flavor, success in capturing the sentiment of the oppressed and marginalized citizens, dichotomizing the society in for and against the movement with specific polarization, adopting the strategic rigidity and tactical flexibility as per the contemporary national and international scenario.
Political compromise is mandatory for all the political parties; and the peace process and the constitution writing process are near conclusion with the positive attitude of all the political parties towards the recent political development. The tactical flexibility and strategic rigidity of the leadership of New Democratic Revolution has finally led the peace process near to conclusion.
Therefore, a pragmatic approach with the up to date analysis of the national and international milieu is the first and foremost factor for the uprising of any political movement and for the socio-economic transformation through new constitution.
Finally constitution writing is mainly political task which is guiding by their political ideology and thought. Political thought based on classical approach but constitution writing is a practical context and based on changing context. Classical approach and changing context of 21st century could have a contradiction. This contradiction is going to reflect in constitution writing process of Nepal.
Legal and Political Aspects
By
Attorney/CA Member
KHIMLAL DEVKOTA
SUBMITTED TO
KYOTO UNIVERSITY,JAPAN
3rd Dec 2011
contents
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 2
Part One 3
1 INTRODUCTION 3
1.1 General introduction 3
Part Two 3
2 THEORITICAL DEVELOPMENT 3
2.1 Historical facts about revolution: 3
2.2 Reassessment of Nepali history 4
2.3 Establishment of Objectives 5
Part Three 5
3 IMPLEMENTATION 5
3.1 Class analysis: force of the revolution 6
3.2 Findings of analysis: possible problems 6
3.3 Series of tactics envisioned 6
3.4 Development of MLM: Nepal's specific as "Prachandapath" 7
3.5 Development of democracy in 21st century 7
Part Four 8
4 PRACTICAL DEVELOPMENT OF MLM IN NEPALI CONTEXT 8
4.1 Chunbang meeting: major event 9
4.2 Kamidanda meeting: major event 9
4.3 Balaju -Kharipati-Palungtar and Parisdanda: 9
Part Five 10
5 TACTICAL FLEXIBILITY AND STRATEGIC RIGIDITY 10
5.1 Tactics and strategies 10
Part Six 12
6 MAJOR ACHIEVEMENTS 12
Part Seven 12
7 Political development and constitution writing process 12
8 CONCLUSION 13
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Nepal, country with full of diversity in terms of geography, culture, economy, religion, ethnicity social characters and structures and several others, is fertile for creating revolutionary environment. On this backdrop, various political movements have engaged us of which a decade long people's war is the most prominent of all. The first part of the paper deals with general background of the character of the Nepalese society that was fertile for fueling the various political and revolutionary movements.
Second part deals with theoretical aspect of the Maoist movement in Nepal, theoretical development on the basis of historical fact, reassessment of historical development, understanding of ground reality of Nepalese society to begin the people's movement and the detailed analysis of the characteristics of Nepalese society and envisioning the pragmatic path to make it compatible with Marxism in contemporary situation. Concrete analysis of concrete situation is a maxim is trying to apply in Nepali context.
Part three is focused on theoretical development of MLM in Nepalese context and its implementation. Pragmatic approach of the MLM in Nepal and its maneuver to explain class analysis based on the finding of problems on strategy and tactics adopted by Russian model of revolution or Chinese model and model of democracy in 21st century are embodied in this section.
Fourth part of the paper explains the practical development of Marxism in Nepal context with some popularly known events such as Chunbang meeting, Balaju, Kharipati, Palungtar plenum and Perisdanda meeting.
The fifth part of the paper provides better insight on the experience of tactical flexibility and strategic rigidity and its relevance to the Maoist's movement in Nepal based on my experience. It also highlights our historical responsibility, Marxism, imperialism and the rising of the middle class of 21st century.
Part six is focused on major achievement of the Maoist movement such as declaration of republic, election of CA, inclusiveness, federalism, secularism etc. Part seven highlights the present political condition legal aspects of constitution writing and its linkage to the combatant management. Finally the conclusion which provides the plausible explanation behind the achievements of the Maoist movement in Nepal; and recent political and legal development. It emphasizes on the pragmatic approach with the up to date analysis of the national and international milieu is the first and foremost factor for the uprising of any political movement and for the socio-economic transformation.
Part One
1 INTRODUCTION
1.1 General introduction
Nepal is a landlocked country, which is surrounded from three sides by the expansionist India and in the north surrounded by the reformist China. It has diverse geographical terrain along with diversity in culture, ethnicity, language and climate. A large section of the Nepalese people is spread in different countries for employment, mainly in India for army and other kinds of jobs.
In Nepal, a centralized reactionary state equipped with a modern, powerful and lavish army and a bureaucracy with centralized governing system has been in existence. The economic and resource distribution has been uneven. Nepal is predominantly rural and the exploited peasants, who represent 90% of the total population, are spread in these villages. Centuries of poverty and inequality, social and political exclusion, gender, caste and ethnic based discrimination, skewed distribution of the resources of production, and corruption and bad governance were the primary characteristics of the then Nepalese society. The unwillingness of the state to invest in infrastructure, such as roads, schools, hospitals, electricity, drinking water and irrigation exacerbated social exclusion and structurally embedded poverty. Spatial disparities caused feelings of injustice. These features of the then Nepalese society were predominant in remote areas of Mid-Western and Far-Western Development Regions. Thus the socio-economic condition, geographical isolation, poor governance, centralized governing system, ideological contention, disproportionate allocation of the resources, skewed distribution of resources, historical legacy, development of international strategy on socio-economic and military aspects, conflicting interests of international actors, royal coup and development of national politics etc. fuelled the revolutionary movement.
Part Two
2 THEORITICAL DEVELOPMENT
2.1 Historical facts about revolution:
History of the Nepalese communist party dates back to half a century but those initiatives were without any tangible achievements. Nepali Congress adopted the armed struggle in pursuit of democracy against the tyranny of Rana regime at the time when the spawning communist movements were not in their capacity to adopt it. Later on, the communist movement has taken various forms and essences with the popular support. However the fledging communist movements were mired by intra party struggle, rifts and division and this has became the characteristic of the communist parties. The time period of around 1950's Jhapa Revolt, 1972, 1980's and 90's movements were led by communist parties but most of them were mass-movements not related with communist movement. Communist parties were limited to reading, writing, publishing statements, division and counter and encounter each other. So, without proper reassessment of the situation another revolution was out of imagination.
2.2 Reassessment of Nepali history
In order to develop the tactics for the people's revolt, the party reassessed the history and its legacy. Through the reassessment the party identified the following facts about the Nepali history
A. The analysis of the reactionaries that the king and monarch are deep-rooted in the Nepalese society is not true. The tradition of the Nepalese society has not been monarchist but democratic and autonomy-oriented.
B. The shameful defeat in the war with British-India and nature of the treaty signed indicate the contradiction and alliance of feudalism and imperialism and led Nepal to semi-colonial state. But this treaty however exposed the national capitalist character of feudal ruling classes and thus nurtured the development of patriotic and national feeling of modern sense amongst the people.
C. Needs to lay the foundation of a consolidated national unity on the basis of equality and freedom in accordance with the right of nations to self-determination for the new democratic revolution was assessed.
D. Observing the fall of Rana Regime it was reassessed that the Party should always make efforts and struggle to be flexible with due consideration to the fluidity of other political groups and to protect itself from its influence.
E. The major subjective factor behind the failure in making due political advancement even after the continuous struggle of the Nepalese people since around 1950 and their dedication, devotion and sacrifices displayed in them, is nothing but the reformism and revisionism dominant in the Nepalese communist movement.
As a result of reassessment of the history of Nepali society, governance and political movements, following realities were recognized.
o Nepal was recognized as a semi-feudal & semi-colonial country reeling under the double exploitation & oppression of feudalism & imperialism with large proportion of population (more than 91%) constitutes of the pauperized, landless, and poor and lower class peasants scattered over the vast rural areas.
o The skewed socio-economic condition and lack of political consciousness among the general public, qualitative and quantitative weakness of the modern working class due to underdevelopment of the industries in the cities leveraged the power of the enemies that are centralized in the city. And the enemies are much more powerful as compared to that of the revolutionaries.
o According to the experiences of class struggle in the era of imperialism, it is possible to develop a militant & revolutionary Party, new culture & revolutionary people’s movement and to bring about radical change in society only by moving ahead along the path of People’s War from the very beginning.
o It was finally recognized that to lead revolution is to lead the people's war.
In conclusion, it was found that
• Even general reforms taken as a byproduct of violent and illegal struggle. The reactionary propaganda that the Nepalese people are peace loving and that they don’t like violence is absolutely false.
• Nepali peoples are great warrior of the world. In national context, from the year 1951 onwards, mainly the Nepalese peasants and other sections of the people have been joining in countless number of violent & armed conflicts against the reactionary state and the anti-establishment feelings among the Nepalese people has been very strong.
• Finally it was concluded that fighting against imperialist, feudal forces and the reactionaries is greatest responsibility of the New Democratic Revolution because the revisionist elements have been time & again ditching & conspiring against the fighting tendency of the Nepalese people.
2.3 Establishment of Objectives
To attain the goal of establishing a New Democratic republic the following policies were formulated:
1. To oppose the monarchical parliamentary multi-party system and to accelerate propagandist agitation in favor of the New Democratic system.
2. To build a revolutionary, militant and new type of Communist Party.
3. To build a revolutionary united Front as an instrument of struggle and an embryo of the new power.
4. To lay emphasis on the preparations of people’s war.
5. To develop a patriotic and democratic movement against feudalism, imperialism and Indian expansionism.
6. To accelerate rural class struggle centering on the slogan of land to the tiller and to concentrate main force on the same.
7. To develop class and mass organizations, to establish Party leadership over them and to develop people’s movement in favor of their problems.
8. To pay special attention to expand the Party to lower classes, oppressed ethnic groups, tribes and depressed castes and to the rural and remote areas.
9. To accord priority to the illegal works and works in the rural areas, to develop as secondary activities the legal and urban works and coordinate the two spheres of activities.
10. To support national liberation, New Democratic and socialist movements all over the world, to emphasize on proletarian internationalism and to develop relations and contacts with the fraternal parties and organizations the world over.
11. To oppose & expose all forms of revisionism.
12. To propagate Marxism-Leninism-Maoism in a systematic manner.
Part Three
3 IMPLEMENTATION
3.1 Class analysis: force of the revolution
For the implementation of the New Democratic Revolution, the Nepali Society was analyzed and classified into the following categories based on their possible contribution and attitude towards the new Democratic Revolution. It was believed that the categorization could be beneficial for the development of the tactics and strategies for the advancement of the revolution. These major motivating forces identified for the New Democratic Revolution were:
• The Proletariat,
• The Farm Workers,
• Middle Peasants,
• Rich Peasants,
• Petty - Bourgeois Class and
• National Bourgeoisie.
3.2 Findings of analysis: possible problems
In the present era of imperialism & proletarian revolution, the enemy class is practicing various forms of conspiratorial strategies to stop revolution in countries like ours. Amongst them we must focus our attention on the following, because we can’t arrive at a correct strategy without understanding the strategy of the enemy. The major advantages that the enemy class has over the revolutionary class are:
1. Monopolistic hold over the communication over the whole world at this time can help the enemy to launch a disinformation campaign with deliberate propaganda about ‘terrorism’, ‘fall of socialism’ and the superiority and success of capitalism and is attempting to lower the morale of the people through the strategy of psychological warfare.
2. All the imperialist forces and the reactionary ruling classes of each country are campaigning strategically by spreading the network of well trained and technically equipped spies.
3. Inventing new forms of reforms & democracy in order to confuse the people politically.
4. Establishment of the networks of NGOs and INGOs have been spread in order to engage some educated middle class people, to prevent them from falling below the middle class and to entrap the people in the petty reformist mirage.
5. Encouraged unemployed youths to get scattered all over the world and to wander in India in the name of employment.
6. Polluting the minds of the people through propagation of religion and other means after entering into rural areas with attractive slogans.
3.3 Series of tactics envisioned
In our situation, the armed struggle can be initiated, sustained and developed only through a skillful implementation of a policy which would go like this:
• Give priority to the rural work, but do not leave out the urban work;
• Give priority to illegal struggle, but do not leave out the legal struggle, too;
• Give priority to specific strategic areas, but do not leave out work related to the mass movement, too;
• Give priority to class struggle in rural areas, but do not leave out countrywide struggle, too;
• Give priority to guerrilla actions, but do not leave out political exposure & propaganda, too;
• Give priority to propaganda work within the country but do not leave out worldwide propaganda, too;
• Give priority to build army organization, but do not leave out to build front organizations, too;
• Give priority to relying on one’s own organization and force, but do not miss to forge unity- in- action, to take support & help from international arena.
The successful development of People’s War in Nepal will be governed by decentralized actions based on central policy, by launching actions at different isolated spots of the enemy and by applying large force against small forces in order to get quick victory, by adopting hit & run tactics, by promoting guerrilla actions under the centralized plan from different parts of the country but by giving special attention to specific strategic areas, and as Mao has said, by organizing and mobilizing as many people as possible and as fast as possible and with as good a method as possible while placing the question of capturing political power at the centre.
3.4 Development of MLM: Nepal's specific as "Prachandapath"
The founding of new unity on a new basis laid a concrete ideological and organizational ground for conducting “Rectification Campaign” as directed by the Fourth Extended Meeting of the Central Committee. The same meeting worked out the Fifth Plan for the PW. The Fifth Plan period which had succeeded in lifting the whole People’s War to a new height of development occupies an important place in our Party history for the following reasons-
1. In the very beginning of this plan implementation, death of alternative Politburo Member Com. Suresh Wagle (Basu) established the great martyrdom, high records of sacrifice, intensified the resentment of the masses against the enemies all over the country and established the revolutionary image of the Party among the people.
2. “Rectification Campaign” was conducted by the Central Committee in the middle of the fifth plan strengthened ideological and emotional unity of the Party; and developed substantially the ideological level and efficiency of the Party to fight against the opportunism.
3. During this plan period, qualitatively high-level military successes were achieved in all regions in general and the Western region in particular.
4. At the final stage of this period, all mysteries and characteristics of the Alok trend appearing as ‘left’ liquidations were exposed through strenuous and incessant efforts of Com. Prachanda and others. Indeed, the exposure and synthesis of the Alok trend is a great success of "Rectification Campaign". In essence, this is yet another triumph of the proletarian line led by Com. Prachanda.
3.5 Development of democracy in 21st century
The main essence of the teachings of Marxism-Leninism-Maoism is to advance ahead through continuous revolution by scientifically synthesizing world proletarian movement enriched by the great experiences of revolution and counter-revolution. In giving leadership to the democratic revolution against feudalism and imperialism in Nepal, our Party has been from the very beginning laying emphasis on applying the teachings of MLM, not in the form of dogma but in the form of creative application and development as a “guide to action”. In this great process of applying and developing the teachings of MLM based on the concrete condition of the Nepalese revolution, we have been waging continuous struggle against rightist revisionists as well as the dogmata-revisionists. The Party has already synthesized the discovery at “Prachanda-Path” as a special chain of ideas in the Nepalese revolution based on this development process of class struggle and ideological struggle.
On the basis of experience of history, analysis of present world situation and five years’ enriched experiences of the Nepalese People’s war, the Party’s second historic Conference has made many important political and military syntheses.
The Party
Revolutionary party for 21st century need to be developed into an organizational theory, methodology and system so that they can stop counter-revolution and this is valid even today. This is the problem of application and development of the theory of two-line struggle within the Party and continuous revolution under the dictatorship of the proletariat.
The Army
The experience of revolution and counter-revolution in the 20th Century has clearly shown that if the proletarian class advances ahead with correct revolutionary ideology, policy and programmed then the people can develop from almost zero to the level of an invincible people’s army which can reduce to dust the ultramodern and powerful army of the enemy. But if wrong ideology prevails then the same army can become a weapon of counter-revolution.
The State
Though capture of state power through people’ war under the leadership of the Party of the proletariat was the main theme of the revolution, the experience of 20th century has clearly proved that the question of continuous democratization of the state power is thousand times more difficult and complex than capturing state power. In Nepalese context we have been talking about the liberation of the masses from class, national, regional, and gender oppression; national and regional autonomy along with the rights to self-determination; party freedom for anti-feudal and anti-imperialist forces. In this situation it should be stressed on correctly organizing the right to self-determination of the masses for the continuous democratization of the state.
Thus, only through the appropriate development of the Party, Army and State as stated above that democracy in the twenty-first century would enhance the process of continuous revolution and counter-revolution.
Part Four
4 PRACTICAL DEVELOPMENT OF MLM IN NEPALI CONTEXT
4.1 Chunbang meeting: major event
• Questions of Leadership
• Correct handling of the contradiction or inners struggle
• Tactical swift to focused village to urban
• Alliance with parliamentary political parties against autocratic Monarchy
• Democratic republican
• Proper balance on Nationality and Democracy
• Rectification-self criticism new type of party building
4.2 Kamidanda meeting: major event
• Seize fire agreement
• CPA, AAMA, Interim Constitution
• Tactics series: people’s war, people’s movement; negotiation and diplomatic initiation.
• Joining Interim Government
• Election of CA:
• Formation of government: Under the Leadership of Maoist Party
With deciding election of CA agreement was signed for formation of interim government including Maoist party. After a decade long people’s war Maoist representative became a part of government. Government had fixed their common minimum programmed. Main focus was; socio-economic transformation, constitution writing, integration and rehabilitation of PLA, and democratization of NA.
4.3 Balaju -Kharipati-Palungtar and Parisdanda:
Before CA election, the extended meetings of Balaju was convened and was the first meeting after seize fire. Division was for CA election or different type of revolution backtracking from peace process. Chitwan meeting was held after promulgation of interim constitution and the entire parliament member were participated there with new coat. Then division became between coat and without coat.
Kharipati meeting was held at a time party itself was leading the government with majore portfolio. Again debate was leading the government by top leadership is a kind of give-up revolution. Peace and constitution is a reformist line so line and leadership both became reformist so it is needed to coming back from the government and preparation for revolt. But plan of revolt was not fixed and finalized.
Palungtar plenum was a three line debate. Again it is focused on peace and constitution or people’s revolt. Finally it was undecided extended meeting more than 6 thousand leaders and cadres were gathered there. It was trying to pass the line of people’s revolt without any preparation but finally it was corrected by perisdanda meeting peace and constitution is appropriate line for this moment.
Part Five
5 TACTICAL FLEXIBILITY AND STRATEGIC RIGIDITY
When the Maoists movement was just spawning in Nepal, people used to think Maoists woodenheaded. At the end of the 20th century, when the communist regimes all over the world were dismantling and in Nepal, where multiparty democracy with constitutional monarchy was just established putting down the three decades long authoritarian panchayat regime of the then monarch, the advocating of the armed movement by the Maoists instead of institutionalizing the achievements so far, displeased some people. Thus started Maoists movement, with unfavorable situations inside and outside the territory, in about a decade became the largest party of the country. The demand of the Constituent Assembly dating 60 years back became possible, the two and half centuries old monarchial system came to an end establishing republic and for the pioneer restructuring of the state, constitutional commitment was made to establish federal states ending the unitary state system of ruling. Revolution established the agendas and now these agendas are molting to work on field, their usefulness is being tested. At the end, what the crux of the achievements was has a single answer; flexibility in tactics rigidity in strategy.
5.1 Tactics and strategies
1. Protracted people's war or urban insurrection: The party attempted to manage the new approaches of preparations for New Democratic Revolution. It assimilated that the Nepalese revolution would success neither in the Chinese way nor in the Russian way, but in its own unique style and thus was the achievements possible in such a short period of time. In a document of a meeting after a month of initiation of the war consciously speaks; in the current socioeconomic structure and the development of class struggle, armed struggle is not the appropriate means of capturing the central state power. The formation of human rights organization, making the mechanism of the civil society, journalists and advocates were the subjects of tactical flexibilities.
2. Questions of Leadership: Marxist leaders failed to develop their own successors and the whole movement was negatively affected by the end of the leader. Recognizing the historical fact, the tactic of collective leadership was opted. Leadership is not a nominee, it is grooming up from the revolution was the major tactical development regarding the leadership.
3. Dichotomizing the Society: Exposure of social problems existing in the society after the 1990 political change greatly helped the party to mobilize the people behind their cause by dichotomizing and polarizing the society by the identities such as, 'oppressed-oppressor', 'ruler-ruled', 'poor-rich', 'landlord-landless', and 'patriot-non patriot'. In this way they deepened (and created new) political, social, cultural and economic cleavages. These dichotomies fuelled the already developed feelings of injustice and frustration in the Nepalese people and thus garnered public support.
4. Military Operations: The people's war proceeded with continuous military attacks. In time, though it used to change its tactics by talks, war and so on, in continuous military attacks its territories could be seen vividly. Hindering the recruitment of the army, obstructing the runaway of the army was carried out after the inability to capture an army camp of one company even a preparation of 14 months.
5. Declaration of Base Area: Party concluded to develop base areas not in isolation but in core and periphery based. The areas were categorized as main area, secondary area for propaganda and enemy area.
6. Simultaneously War and Peace: It is possible to launch war and peace at a time. In the field battles are going on and at a top negotiation also going on not only in political level but also possible in military level too.
7. Strategic balance of power: Another specific character of the war is to maintain proper balance with national and international forces and targeting the principal enemy while joining hands with secondary enemies. National forces were divided in two parts for and against as a same manner international forces too.
8. Parallel state power: During the period of armed conflict various state structures such as court system, revenue collection mechanisms, own military and administrative structures were established; and the party asked for International community's including UN for the recognition of those state strucures.
9. Tactical swift: Hindering the recruitment process of the army by threatening the aspirants, calling the army out of the barracks and attacking, making false attacks and drawing the attention of the army away from the attacking points, ambushing the armed force heading to back the ones in the ongoing attack, supply side intervention for various basic needs, etc. were the examples of tactical swift.
10. Rural to Urban Strategy: The formation of human rights organization, making the mechanism of the civil society, journalists and advocates tight and fix may seem confronting and may be said eerie rightist; those were the subjects of tactical flexibilities. On one hand the party is talking of raising arms but on the other hand forms network of human rights organizations, creation of the situation of dilemma was also the tactic of the movement.
11. Agenda for negotiation: CA, Removal of Monarchy, Federalization of state, Inclusion and proportional representation with special rights for dalit and women, feudalism to capitalism move, continuation of revolution and completion of rest task of the revolution.
• The tactic adopted during the mid period of the people's war was round table conference, interim government and the election of the constituent assembly. Seeming extreme rightist; there was no way these slogans suit a revolutionary leftist party but the result of these became a subject to tie the hands of the reactionary forces. The slogan "let's institutionalize republic", after the royal massacre; where there was no smell of the People's Republic; seeming like extreme reformist, prepared a base for the party to achieve the republic. The party that had conducted the people's war with the slogan "let's leap forwards in the path of the people's war in order to establish people's state power" headed forwards saying Constituent assembly, democratic republic, and interim constitution, election of the constituent assembly.
12. Leadership of the government after the election: there was no absolute majority to the party after the election but the leading of the government was decided and executed.
13. Resignation, illegitimate step of the president: while discussing about accomplishment of Nepalese revolution, all of sudden the chapter about chief of the army came into play and quitted from the government by resigning. After a yearlong of street protest, again from the candidacy of prime minister till now, all these events verify tactical flexibility.
The above outlined events are the examples of tactical flexibility adopted by a revolutionary communist party. The more we become flexible in tactics, the more it helps us to become rigid in strategies. If we become rigid in tactics, then we have to be flexible in strategies, and when strategies flexibility is adopted, then there arises a question in idea, policy and principle.
Part Six
6 MAJOR ACHIEVEMENTS
Marx propounded theory; Lenin implemented in Russia as an insurrection; Mao did in China as a protracted people’s war. In Nepal we decided to develop MLM and fusion of both. The tangible achievements of the People's war can be presented in nutshell as:
• Interim Constitution
• Establishment of Republic
• Election of Constituent Assembly
• Inclusiveness in every sector of society
• Proportionate Representation
• Federal structure of the state
• Modality for integration and rehabilitation of the PLA.
Part Seven
7 POLITICAL DEVELOPMENT AND CONSTITUTION WRITING PROCESS
7.1 Our responsibility of changing time:
We are talking about the revolution in the first decade of the 21st century. Our chief responsibility is to develop forthcoming tactics keeping in mind about the characteristics of globalized imperialism, characteristics of the classes and the success and failure of revolutionary movements. We have considered that the base of our acceptance of multiparty competition is the downfall of communist regimes in the 20th century. Also we have to review the fundamental changes in the nature of revolutionary movements, imperialistic character and reactionary class in the first decade of the 21st century based on the deployment of communist regimes of the 20th century. Any discussion of ideas sans this type of review will turn fruitless.
7.2 Imperialism of the 21st century
Imperialism itself is in the changed state. To self sustain, it is in its continuous motion, and with the changed circumstances it is trying its best to modify itself. Being so, the power in chief contradiction with the oppressed nations in on timely change, and if the oppressed nations and classes failed to endorse tactics accordingly, then there is no other alternative than defeat. So, not to be defeated, it is necessary to discuss about today's imperialism and develop today's Marxism putting aside insistence.
Today's imperialism is not in the state of turning mutual contradictions into world war. The situation is of dividing mutual differences according to their interest, power and capability and the nature of such division is not in the state of maintaining colony by dividing traditional geography. Despite this, the imperialistic forces are heading forwards establishing multinational companies and organizations and retaining world management through mutual coordination. The imperialistic interest of this time is to expand its market and to capture the world through that expanded market. For this, they don’t think it necessary to capture a fixed geography.
Imperialism of this stage is in the character of its change from industrial capital to financial capital. Industrial capital is at least extended to investor, workers, manager and production and market that are why the state of supremacy of imperialism only or capital only cannot prevail. It has to maintain its mutual consonance with other parties too. But today, after the change of industrial capital to financial capital, the absolute capital and the absolute imperialistic power, in its solo decision, is in the state of mobilizing that capital. Imperialism uses to accomplish its work through its agents instead of working itself. It such condition, the Marxist methods and norms of the 20th century are insufficient, their development is essential. Ignoring the evolved character of the imperialism, if we managed to define imperialism in the obsolete ways and develop future tactics, there is not a single alternative to defeat.
7.3 Rising of the middle class in the 21st century
The size of classes and their character is changed in this time. There is a rapid rise of the middle class while running in the first decade of the 21st century. The proletariat class and the reactionary class are at decrement and the middle class is making up the maximum. During the middle of the 20th century, the middle class was minimal and any class could ensure victory by its help but now the middle class staying in the middle and those who adopt the tactic that can influence the middle class can achieve victory. In the 20th century, the middle class was unsteady and used to hover sometimes here and sometimes there but now it has become permanent. Based on size and number also this class is in the stage of being determining class. It is necessary to care about this fact.
Additionally, the 1990 political change provided the space to reflect on these problems. Freedom of expression and organization allowed people to pursue a radical agenda, previously not tolerated by the state. Democracy created opportunities for marginalized people to organize themselves to fight for their rights, while at the same time raising the expectations of the people. Politicians in the early 1990's fuelled these expectations to win the popular vote, but, once in power; they failed to address people's concerns. This greatly helped the CPN (M) to mobilize the people behind their cause. The CPN (M) was also very successful at polarizing people into for and against by dichotomizing identities such as 'oppressed-oppressor', 'ruler-ruled', 'poor-rich', 'landlord-landless', and 'patriot-non patriot'. In this way they deepened (and created new) political, social, cultural and economic cleavages. These dichotomies fuelled the already developed feelings of injustice and frustration in the Nepalese people.
7.4 Reality in changing context:
Practically we are talking about writing constitution based on above mentioned particular situation and changing context of the world society. We have a firm believe on Marxism is a concrete analysis of concrete condition. So we have to think about it. Constitution and communism is hard to matching. it is because for communist why it is needed constitution and law. Goal of the communist is Communism and which is, itself is a classless stateless and lawless such type of ideal society. so we can come in conclusion that there is no need of any kind of law and constitution in the stage of communism.
According to Marxist view law is a tools of exploitation it can be used for suppression of the enemy class of people. Class divided society law is used for control and creating a barrier of the changing interest of the people.
Classical Marxism is no more working in 21st century it is firm believer of the Maoist party. This is a key of the Maoist movement . Marxism is not a lifeless dogma it is need to change and update and develop with compatible changing context.
With above mentioned scenario Maoist movement raised a issue of new constitution through elected body as a constituent assembly. First it was started during war by peoples republican constitution. Peoples legal code peoples power and court rules and regulation.
During negotiation time minimum content of the constitution had publicized.
During interim constitution drafting period it has been submitted very comprehensive constitution draft to the interim constitution drafting committee.
After two years of constitution writing has been published next constitution draft based on constituent assembly debate.
Now it is in final phase of constitution drafting. These are the constitutional development of Maoist party itself.
Marxism do believe on result if result is fine doesn’t matter about process but formal democracy always confine within process rather than result it is main contradiction.
Second contradiction is political slogan based politics and materialized in content is very different. Everything need to making new is a slogan but what it is nobody knows. This is another irony.
Along with fundamental principles based confusion and barriers now we are in the final phase of constitution drafting. Presently Nepal is facing two main challenges. Of them, the first is to complete the peace process, which would require a resolution and implementation of the difficult issue of how to integration of the former Maoist combatants into national security forces and reintegration of the combatants into the society. The second key challenge is completing the drafting of a constitution with federal structure, preferential right to self determination and special rights for women and dalits. These issues are the bone of contentions among the major political parties. The political parties are utilizing these agendas to secure their position during the transitional politics. Though these two processes are interlinked with each other, the political parties have different perception regarding this.
Marxism always believes that everything is determined by politics. So it is often said, "Politics in command". However, law and constitution are tools of governance. We cannot imagine a territory without law. In this context, UCPN (M) has had practiced the constitution writing process at the time of peoples war. At the time of negotiation only a part of the content was publicized. Interim constitution drafting time it was hard negotiation about the issues of people's rights and political issues raised by the Maoist party at the time of peoples war such a forward-looking change, state restructuring, proportional representations, inclusion and others. Based on interim constitution party started to draft its own constitution for the peoples and party cadres and leaders too. Party decided to form a constitution drafting committee for the party purposes but it was so difficult to resolve the contrasting issues because we are not in the phase of complete revolution. When we based on debatable issues and settled issues in constituent assembly then draft is going to be a normal it is not serving a spirit of peoples war completely and if we based on the constitution draft of the peoples war time then it will not be accepted in Constitutional Assembly. Compromise is the most essential factor for all the political parties.
Through the peace and constitution writing processes, the UCPN (Maoist) is dynamically working to institutionalize a people’s governing system, a new political system and people’s federal republic where there will be inclusive and proportional representation and participation of the Nepalese people. But the situation within this largest party is not easy as it seems to be. The intraparty rift is deepening within the party regarding the conclusion of the peace process and the constitution writing. Expressing dissent against the final effort to ensure people’s right through peace and constitution, a faction within the Maoists is trying to end all the achievements concealing under revolutionary veil. Stepping outside the disciplinary boundary of revolutionaries and making mockery of the principles of a communist party, they are raising debate of no use for namesake.
The old ruler, especially the Nepali Congress who fears the existence, is standing against these changes and the CPN (UML) is hovering around the NC's position. The fear of existence is further fuelled by the intra party rift in all the major political parties. In a shameful effort, old rulers are ignoring the agreements of the CPA.
The major debates in the Constituent Assembly are:
Different understanding of Rules of law, democracy, independence of judiciary, separation of power etc. terms monopolized by the traditional political parties are hard to accept and adopt by the party arising through the New Democratic Revolution. Even most of the leaders are not familiar with the terms of the constitution some of the words are already became monopoly of it.
People's war was conducted with the overwhelming support of the society. Furthermore, the New Democratic Revolution has inculcated in public that everything should be new. But it would be possible only if the revolution was complete. But party is in the state of compromise. Compromise by all the political parties is the reality of the present day situation, but intention is the constitution with revolutionary spirit. Question arises, how we can balance it?
Another most important aspect of the Nepalese contemporary politics is that focus of the politics is always in slogan rather than technical details. Political interest cannot serve only by slogan. For the purpose of the fulfillment of the political interest need to have technical details. Gap between political slogan and technical details must be fulfilled by the proper balance between the two for the tangible outcome of the peace process.
Whatever disagreement there may be, in recent days all the major leaders of the major political parties are harping the slogan of agreement and this has inculcated the ray of hope in all Nepali people and the international community.
8 CONCLUSION
Political stand based on classical Marxism and writing constitution in 21st century is quite contrast. Constitution at present is matter of fact and classical Marxism is a philosophy. Philosophy materialization in constitution of 21st century is not a easy job.
Even though, Finally Maoist party has taken historical initiation for the liberation of the people. For this purpose it has developed its own clear objectives; it has developed its own style and methods. It has been highly appreciated by the other communist parties. The path taken by the Maoist party in Nepal is a new and unique to its soil. It doesn’t match with any practices of Marxism as it is a redefined mode so orthodox types of communist parties regard it as a reformist. Whether the movement is reformist or revolutionary let the future to judge it.
The plausible explanation behind the achievements of the People's war in nutshell are; strong leadership capability, initial brushing off of the grievances as the unrealistic ambition by the state authorities, modality adopted of local flavor, success in capturing the sentiment of the oppressed and marginalized citizens, dichotomizing the society in for and against the movement with specific polarization, adopting the strategic rigidity and tactical flexibility as per the contemporary national and international scenario.
Political compromise is mandatory for all the political parties; and the peace process and the constitution writing process are near conclusion with the positive attitude of all the political parties towards the recent political development. The tactical flexibility and strategic rigidity of the leadership of New Democratic Revolution has finally led the peace process near to conclusion.
Therefore, a pragmatic approach with the up to date analysis of the national and international milieu is the first and foremost factor for the uprising of any political movement and for the socio-economic transformation through new constitution.
Finally constitution writing is mainly political task which is guiding by their political ideology and thought. Political thought based on classical approach but constitution writing is a practical context and based on changing context. Classical approach and changing context of 21st century could have a contradiction. This contradiction is going to reflect in constitution writing process of Nepal.
Friday, September 9, 2011
Japan India and Nepal Global Partnership Summit 2011 On Strategic Vision for Next Decade.
India Japan global Partnership summit 2011
4-7th September, 2011
Tokyo Japan
Speech delivered by Khimlal Devkota
Mr. Chairman distinguish guest, speakers, participants ladies and gentleman,
First of all I would like to express my sincere thanks to the organizer for inviting me and giving me an opportunity in this august gathering. India Japan Global Partnership summit 2011.
I am from Nepal, a country which is now in a peace process after a decade long people's war. In case of Nepal, conflict evolved against the autocratic feudal monarchial unitary system which forced the people to live in a miserable life; in poverty, illiteracy and week socio- economic conditions. Nepal inter in peace process in 2006, after signing on comprehensive Peace accord. We have identified integration and rehabilitation of People's liberation Army (PLA), Constitution formulation and the socio-economic transformation as the major tasks to achieve a sustainable peace.
Indeed, the peace accord in the struggle against feudal monarchy and oligarchy was a grand success. However, Nepal is now at a transitional phase. Time and again, peace process is obstructed when political parties in the country fail to consolidate on a common agenda for peace. We are feeling diffulities to create a sustainable political environment in the country. The weak socio-economic condition of the country has been as major challenge in the peace process and post-conflict restructuring of the country. As you all now know that, Nepal is drafting its constitution through constituent Assembly, through their elected representatives. We aimed to represent all sector, identities and diversities in the constitution. Moreover, it has become a test for direct use of people's sovereignty. Thus, our new constitution must be a codification of people's rights. If we confined again in only civil and political rights but failed to address the socio-economic rights of the people, root cause of conflict may not be abolish. We believe, the constitution must guarantee socio-economic and cultural rights of the people.
Through New constitution we must have to fix our political and economic system at least.
Political system:
Coming to the second decade of 21st century, the innovation in science and technology has expanded their ambit. I do believe politics was and politics is always in command. In the last century, Japan went through bad has bad experiences of war and India had bitter experiences of British colony. Sadly, Nepal is still suffering from its history of feudal autocratic monarchial unitary system and its hangover.
Parliamentary systems or the presidential system, both have merits and demerits. Besides, now its proven that we cannot generalize a specific system to be the perfect one for all the countries. There is a need of a rethink and revise these systems in accordance with demand of the diversified issue of the specific country and the emerging global economy. Today, strong economic system and a strong political system have become each other's support. If political system collapses, it creates a negative effect on the economic sector. Similarly, an economic system can sustain only in sustainable and suitable political system. This is an opportunity to draw attention for new and pro-people political system for themselves and for others too. India and Japan both countries are having parliamentary system they had maintained their status quo but not able to resolve their own problems. Especially, why does, India, the country with 60 years old democracy has the largest number of poorest population in the world? , why are there defragmentation among the people and different groups are marching against the system and are broadening their area scale day by day? So, why not rethink about parliamentary system. Why not to research and find out the root causes of devastating conflicts that we aim to eliminate from countries?
Economic system:
Around the world peoples are facing their own problems government and establishment is also in same condition. Frankly speaking, socialism and capitalism both were success in the past era but now it is in 21st century always in questions. We cannot deny that, communism was in one of the ruling position in the 1st half of the 20th century. However, with the disintegration of the USSR, rumor spread out analyzing it as an s failure of the Marxism. Flowingly, capitalism dominated the world. Many nations claimed it to be the best system. But sadly, the economic crisis in the 1st decade of the 21st century has challenged capitalism. Many of us have anlysised it as a failure of capitalism. So, now it's time to come together and find a better sustainable system which will, in true sense create an economic world of mutual prosperity. Let's reassessment the growing economy and reform our angle to view the specific sectors and our priorities.
People's relation:
Political dynamics is changing now. Only the formal relation institutional relations of a country to country can't do everything. There is a need to establish people to people informal relations and promote non-governmental l relation and track 2 relations. Peoples are everywhere if people are ignored then strong establishments also can be challenged and questioned. Pro people policy and policy owned by the people, oversight by the people and guided by the people must be a slogan for policy makers.
Challenges: Gap between haves and have not is going bigger.
Ladies and Gentlemen, just think even if we believe everyone has equal rights, some of the peoples are still deprive from state power and state services. Though, legally they are all equal but among those equals many of them are unable to access equal power and rights. Sadly, in the same state there are people who have power to monopolizing state mechanism and for their own benefits. The outcome of this type of social structure is violence and tension. This type of tension can only be address by inclusion sharing power and ensure access to state power.
Poor people are our main stakeholders:
If we study the population structure, we can see mass of poor people as a poor people. These poor people are largest part of our populations. Thus, I believe these people must be the main stakeholder of the economic development, user of state power and order of the state power. If we forget to include them in our economic policies, we are missing the biggest target.
If look deep into major tensions and conflicts in our societies, Poverty, illiteracy, exploitation and suppression are the sources of these conflict and revolution. Constitutional and legitimate formal institutions or rule of law have failed to function in the countries with poverty, illiteracy, exploitation and so on.
Resources sharing are a big deal:
Politics, business, service and all other sectors are confined in collection and capture the resources. Not to forget that all resources are equal for all. Access to resources and sharing of resources is right of the all people but it is hard to seen in practice.
Ownership and production relation:
State assets, natural resources are equal for its people. However, the society has different classes of people. Thus, ironically, equality in the use of these resources is only exercised only among that equal mass which are equal. But what about the mass that is not equal and cant not but the mass which is not equal and cannot have access to such resources? There is a huge mass of populations are unable to exercise their so called equal rights as equal opportunities and as they lack equal access to these resources. Who made the rule that poor people cannot use the resources and the products on which they have equal rights? If the recourses are equal for all, why cannot a poor person cannot be the owner of the resources and product and neither a factory too?
We have huge masses of the poor and deprived people who contribute the production at the same time world is suffering from the Industrial capital changing and replacing by financial capital which is also main challenges.
Each and every sector is spread out throughout the world and the World is looks like a global village. Market is focused on profit rather than need of the people and service of the people. More profit can be achieved from financial capital then industrial capital. As a result the unemployment is increasing day by day. The complete sift of industrial capital into financial capital will collapse employment opportunities would completely. As in the history, when masses of the peoples are detached from the resources any kind of capital, it generates frustration, and anger creating violent revolutions and struggle against industrial financial capital.
Prosperities: Nepal is in the phase of constitution writing and at a time nation building and constitution building. This is a time to focus on special topics like political and economic system within the political system. Newest constitution from Nepal can be a model for others countries to study the new trend of socio-economic revolution. Moreover, we are egger to know the experiences and suggestions of other countries to have an effective socio-economic movement form the grassroots level.
Diversities:
21st century is a time of identity politics. If any political party does not accept it, it's definite that it will collapse. Nepal is country of diversity. Diversity is not a liability; it is an asset of the country. However, if the issue of diversity is not addressed properly, it will create tensions everywhere. Those who can manage and use the population diversity in positive and productive way would success. So, acceptance and proper addressing and capitalization of diversity within people is very important issues that the world can learn from Nepal.
Tourism:
Nepal, Japan, and India, each of these countries have high potentiality of tourism. Different level of population can be managing religious tourism, business tourism, and technological tourism. These can promote a healthy and productive exchange of different kind of ideas, culture and practices. Lord Buddha’s birth place is in Nepal, Japan as a Buddhist country can promote tourism in Nepal. Similarly, India can attract Nepal's largest Hindu communities. Specialist of three countries can sit together and plan for different tourism packages in these three countries with diversities in climate, culture and entire differences in way of living.
Human resources:
Nepal has the Young and working population is in Nepal. 2/3 population of Nepal is 18-45 age group where is the old age population is comparatively low. Nepali human resources can highly be useful for Japan and for Nepal it would an opportunity to learn the latest technology and use the experiences of Japan in the home country.
Natural resources:
Nepal is a nature gift country everywhere it is full of natural beauty which can be use as a tourism industry and development of national economic development. Several known and unknown Herbal products are also in Nepal. Which can be explore more and more with the help of develop country. Donation grant and loan in productive and doable sector must be identified.
Tension minimizes:
Everywhere is full of tense heavy investment on war industry cannot contribute for peace. Japan and India can play a vital role about to change a war economy to peace economy, destructive economy to constructive economy. Together we can create a world of no armies and wars but a world with schools and pollution free natural environment for the future generation.
Equality, co-existences:
Equality and co-existence is a spirit of the whole world but no one has taken as it in real life. Equality and co existence is a very sensitive matter. We cannot see them in concrete but can feel the sense. If we could properly handle them; peace, harmony, prosperity and development can flourish. Nepal India and Japan has series of commonalities and differences. Politically Capitalism-market economy vs. socialist economy: Countries that have been facing such event now they became a new economic super power.
At last, but not the least, I believe, Japan's global partnership, including India which is one of the Neighbor of Nepal will certainly benefit Nepal and the Asian subcontinent. I believe also believe that it will promote to create a sustainable economy and everlasting peace in the world. More specifically, Nepal would be glad to get friendly hands from Japan and India in its mission to achieve a nation of people with equal rights and opportunities and re construct the country with a tremendous socio-economic change.
Thank you !
How the new socio-economic framework evolving between India and Japan can serve as a model to emulate for global Patterned countries. The India Japan relationship is bound to acquire even greater significance as the Asian region goes through tremendous socio-economic and geopolitical changes and as the international scene rapidly evolves, the session tries to define micro-vision of Japan Global Parternership.
Suggest Policy level changes. Which will encompass Nepal in the India Japan Global Parternership Initiative.
Identify areas of cooperation and what is needed on policy level from Nepal Japan and India.
4-7th September, 2011
Tokyo Japan
Speech delivered by Khimlal Devkota
Mr. Chairman distinguish guest, speakers, participants ladies and gentleman,
First of all I would like to express my sincere thanks to the organizer for inviting me and giving me an opportunity in this august gathering. India Japan Global Partnership summit 2011.
I am from Nepal, a country which is now in a peace process after a decade long people's war. In case of Nepal, conflict evolved against the autocratic feudal monarchial unitary system which forced the people to live in a miserable life; in poverty, illiteracy and week socio- economic conditions. Nepal inter in peace process in 2006, after signing on comprehensive Peace accord. We have identified integration and rehabilitation of People's liberation Army (PLA), Constitution formulation and the socio-economic transformation as the major tasks to achieve a sustainable peace.
Indeed, the peace accord in the struggle against feudal monarchy and oligarchy was a grand success. However, Nepal is now at a transitional phase. Time and again, peace process is obstructed when political parties in the country fail to consolidate on a common agenda for peace. We are feeling diffulities to create a sustainable political environment in the country. The weak socio-economic condition of the country has been as major challenge in the peace process and post-conflict restructuring of the country. As you all now know that, Nepal is drafting its constitution through constituent Assembly, through their elected representatives. We aimed to represent all sector, identities and diversities in the constitution. Moreover, it has become a test for direct use of people's sovereignty. Thus, our new constitution must be a codification of people's rights. If we confined again in only civil and political rights but failed to address the socio-economic rights of the people, root cause of conflict may not be abolish. We believe, the constitution must guarantee socio-economic and cultural rights of the people.
Through New constitution we must have to fix our political and economic system at least.
Political system:
Coming to the second decade of 21st century, the innovation in science and technology has expanded their ambit. I do believe politics was and politics is always in command. In the last century, Japan went through bad has bad experiences of war and India had bitter experiences of British colony. Sadly, Nepal is still suffering from its history of feudal autocratic monarchial unitary system and its hangover.
Parliamentary systems or the presidential system, both have merits and demerits. Besides, now its proven that we cannot generalize a specific system to be the perfect one for all the countries. There is a need of a rethink and revise these systems in accordance with demand of the diversified issue of the specific country and the emerging global economy. Today, strong economic system and a strong political system have become each other's support. If political system collapses, it creates a negative effect on the economic sector. Similarly, an economic system can sustain only in sustainable and suitable political system. This is an opportunity to draw attention for new and pro-people political system for themselves and for others too. India and Japan both countries are having parliamentary system they had maintained their status quo but not able to resolve their own problems. Especially, why does, India, the country with 60 years old democracy has the largest number of poorest population in the world? , why are there defragmentation among the people and different groups are marching against the system and are broadening their area scale day by day? So, why not rethink about parliamentary system. Why not to research and find out the root causes of devastating conflicts that we aim to eliminate from countries?
Economic system:
Around the world peoples are facing their own problems government and establishment is also in same condition. Frankly speaking, socialism and capitalism both were success in the past era but now it is in 21st century always in questions. We cannot deny that, communism was in one of the ruling position in the 1st half of the 20th century. However, with the disintegration of the USSR, rumor spread out analyzing it as an s failure of the Marxism. Flowingly, capitalism dominated the world. Many nations claimed it to be the best system. But sadly, the economic crisis in the 1st decade of the 21st century has challenged capitalism. Many of us have anlysised it as a failure of capitalism. So, now it's time to come together and find a better sustainable system which will, in true sense create an economic world of mutual prosperity. Let's reassessment the growing economy and reform our angle to view the specific sectors and our priorities.
People's relation:
Political dynamics is changing now. Only the formal relation institutional relations of a country to country can't do everything. There is a need to establish people to people informal relations and promote non-governmental l relation and track 2 relations. Peoples are everywhere if people are ignored then strong establishments also can be challenged and questioned. Pro people policy and policy owned by the people, oversight by the people and guided by the people must be a slogan for policy makers.
Challenges: Gap between haves and have not is going bigger.
Ladies and Gentlemen, just think even if we believe everyone has equal rights, some of the peoples are still deprive from state power and state services. Though, legally they are all equal but among those equals many of them are unable to access equal power and rights. Sadly, in the same state there are people who have power to monopolizing state mechanism and for their own benefits. The outcome of this type of social structure is violence and tension. This type of tension can only be address by inclusion sharing power and ensure access to state power.
Poor people are our main stakeholders:
If we study the population structure, we can see mass of poor people as a poor people. These poor people are largest part of our populations. Thus, I believe these people must be the main stakeholder of the economic development, user of state power and order of the state power. If we forget to include them in our economic policies, we are missing the biggest target.
If look deep into major tensions and conflicts in our societies, Poverty, illiteracy, exploitation and suppression are the sources of these conflict and revolution. Constitutional and legitimate formal institutions or rule of law have failed to function in the countries with poverty, illiteracy, exploitation and so on.
Resources sharing are a big deal:
Politics, business, service and all other sectors are confined in collection and capture the resources. Not to forget that all resources are equal for all. Access to resources and sharing of resources is right of the all people but it is hard to seen in practice.
Ownership and production relation:
State assets, natural resources are equal for its people. However, the society has different classes of people. Thus, ironically, equality in the use of these resources is only exercised only among that equal mass which are equal. But what about the mass that is not equal and cant not but the mass which is not equal and cannot have access to such resources? There is a huge mass of populations are unable to exercise their so called equal rights as equal opportunities and as they lack equal access to these resources. Who made the rule that poor people cannot use the resources and the products on which they have equal rights? If the recourses are equal for all, why cannot a poor person cannot be the owner of the resources and product and neither a factory too?
We have huge masses of the poor and deprived people who contribute the production at the same time world is suffering from the Industrial capital changing and replacing by financial capital which is also main challenges.
Each and every sector is spread out throughout the world and the World is looks like a global village. Market is focused on profit rather than need of the people and service of the people. More profit can be achieved from financial capital then industrial capital. As a result the unemployment is increasing day by day. The complete sift of industrial capital into financial capital will collapse employment opportunities would completely. As in the history, when masses of the peoples are detached from the resources any kind of capital, it generates frustration, and anger creating violent revolutions and struggle against industrial financial capital.
Prosperities: Nepal is in the phase of constitution writing and at a time nation building and constitution building. This is a time to focus on special topics like political and economic system within the political system. Newest constitution from Nepal can be a model for others countries to study the new trend of socio-economic revolution. Moreover, we are egger to know the experiences and suggestions of other countries to have an effective socio-economic movement form the grassroots level.
Diversities:
21st century is a time of identity politics. If any political party does not accept it, it's definite that it will collapse. Nepal is country of diversity. Diversity is not a liability; it is an asset of the country. However, if the issue of diversity is not addressed properly, it will create tensions everywhere. Those who can manage and use the population diversity in positive and productive way would success. So, acceptance and proper addressing and capitalization of diversity within people is very important issues that the world can learn from Nepal.
Tourism:
Nepal, Japan, and India, each of these countries have high potentiality of tourism. Different level of population can be managing religious tourism, business tourism, and technological tourism. These can promote a healthy and productive exchange of different kind of ideas, culture and practices. Lord Buddha’s birth place is in Nepal, Japan as a Buddhist country can promote tourism in Nepal. Similarly, India can attract Nepal's largest Hindu communities. Specialist of three countries can sit together and plan for different tourism packages in these three countries with diversities in climate, culture and entire differences in way of living.
Human resources:
Nepal has the Young and working population is in Nepal. 2/3 population of Nepal is 18-45 age group where is the old age population is comparatively low. Nepali human resources can highly be useful for Japan and for Nepal it would an opportunity to learn the latest technology and use the experiences of Japan in the home country.
Natural resources:
Nepal is a nature gift country everywhere it is full of natural beauty which can be use as a tourism industry and development of national economic development. Several known and unknown Herbal products are also in Nepal. Which can be explore more and more with the help of develop country. Donation grant and loan in productive and doable sector must be identified.
Tension minimizes:
Everywhere is full of tense heavy investment on war industry cannot contribute for peace. Japan and India can play a vital role about to change a war economy to peace economy, destructive economy to constructive economy. Together we can create a world of no armies and wars but a world with schools and pollution free natural environment for the future generation.
Equality, co-existences:
Equality and co-existence is a spirit of the whole world but no one has taken as it in real life. Equality and co existence is a very sensitive matter. We cannot see them in concrete but can feel the sense. If we could properly handle them; peace, harmony, prosperity and development can flourish. Nepal India and Japan has series of commonalities and differences. Politically Capitalism-market economy vs. socialist economy: Countries that have been facing such event now they became a new economic super power.
At last, but not the least, I believe, Japan's global partnership, including India which is one of the Neighbor of Nepal will certainly benefit Nepal and the Asian subcontinent. I believe also believe that it will promote to create a sustainable economy and everlasting peace in the world. More specifically, Nepal would be glad to get friendly hands from Japan and India in its mission to achieve a nation of people with equal rights and opportunities and re construct the country with a tremendous socio-economic change.
Thank you !
How the new socio-economic framework evolving between India and Japan can serve as a model to emulate for global Patterned countries. The India Japan relationship is bound to acquire even greater significance as the Asian region goes through tremendous socio-economic and geopolitical changes and as the international scene rapidly evolves, the session tries to define micro-vision of Japan Global Parternership.
Suggest Policy level changes. Which will encompass Nepal in the India Japan Global Parternership Initiative.
Identify areas of cooperation and what is needed on policy level from Nepal Japan and India.
Tuesday, August 16, 2011
शान्ति प्रकृयाका जटिलता र समाधानका उपायहरु
शान्ति र संविधान नेपाली जनताको एकमात्र चाहना हुदा हुदै पनि सो चाहना पुरा गर्न नेपाली राजनीतिक दल र तिनका नेताहरुलाई हम्मे हम्मे परेको छ । आखिर यसो हुनमा के त्यस्तो तत्वले काम गरेको छ । यसका जिम्मेवार पक्षहरु के के र को को होलान वा शान्ति प्रकृयाका जटिलताहरु नै होलान वा यसका जटिलताहरु हुन भने ति के के होलान यसै विषयमा संक्षेपमा चर्चा गर्ने प्रयत्न गरिएको छ ।
शान्ति प्रकृयाको आरम्भ ऐतिहासिक १२ वुदेवाट भएको हो । सो सहमति तत्कालिन सात दल र माओवादीका वीच भएको भएतापनि दुवै पक्षको औपचारिक हस्ताक्षर समारोह भएर हुन सकेको अवस्था हैन । अझ भनौ विगत दश वर्ष एक आपसमा लडेका शक्तिहरु कै वीचमा भएको सहमति थियो सो १२ वुदे सहमति । तसर्थ यो नै नेपाली राजनीतिको अनौठो अवस्था हो र मौलिकता पनि हो । खासगरी दश वर्ष भन्दा वढी अवधि एक आपसमा लडेका दलहरु एक अर्कालाई आतंककारी भनेका दलहरु एक अर्कालाई सके सम्म सिध्याउने भनेर लागेका दलहरु एका एक मिल्ने वातावरण यसकारणले तयार भयो जसका निम्ति ज्ञानेन्द्रको शाही कदम जिम्मेवार थियो । ज्ञानेन्द्रको लात र माओवादीको हातले तत्कालिन सात दल र माओवादी मिलन सम्भव भएको थियो भन्न्ो भनाई पनि निकै चर्चा छ । यो अवस्था ज्ञानेन्द्रको शासनकाल सम्म सकि्रय वा निष्किृय दुवै अवधिसम्म त सम्भव भयो तर जव गणतन्त्रको घोषणा गरियो र राजतन्त्रलाई सदाकालागि विदायी गरियो तव एकापसमा शत्रु खोज्ने वानी परेका राजनैतिक दलहरुले शत्रु खोज्नै थाले र यसो गर्दा अरु कोही थिएन एक अर्कालाई नै देख्न थाले समस्या र जलिता यहीवाट आरम्भ भएको थियो । यसका अतिरिक्त अरु विषयहरु केवल निमित्त कारण मात्रै रहे ।
एकापसमा एक दशक लडेका र दुई वर्ष मात्रै मिलेका दलहरु फेरि एक अर्कामा शत्रु घोषणा गर्ने तहसम्म पुगेका दलहरु वीचको आपसी सम्वन्ध जटिल हुनु स्वभाविक नै थियो यसैको परिणाम शान्ति प्रकृयामा जटिलताहरु आई परेका हुन यसको उचित समाधान नखोजीकन शान्ति प्रकृयाका जटिलताहरु पहिचान र निदान दुवै संभव छैन ।
१२ वुदे सहमतिः
शान्ति प्रकृयाको थालनी यही विन्दुवाट भएको थियो । यस सहमतिमा शान्ति् प्रकृयाका विषयमा भन्दा पनि शाही निरंकुशताको अन्तमा वढी जोड दिईएको थियो । शाही निरंकुताको अन्त पछि राज्यको रुपान्तरण र शान्ति प्रकृया कसरी अघि वढछ भन्ने वारेमा पनि सामान्य रोडम्याप तयार भएको थियो तर सो रोडम्याप शर्तवन्दी थियेा राजतन्त्रको उपस्थितिमा त्यो शर्त वन्दी स्वभाविक पनि थियो विश्वास योग्य पनि थियो सवैकालागि अपरिहार्य पनि थियो तर राजतन्त्रको अन्त संगै राज्यको रुपान्तरणका विषय जनमुक्ति सेनाको समायोजनको विषय र शाही सेनाको लोकतान्त्रिकरण गर्ने विषय निकै जटिल वनेर आई पुगे । १२ वुदेको औपचारिक र अनौपचारिक सहमति र समझदारीमा वुझाई र आत्मसातीकरणमा देखिएको भिन्नता नै शान्ति प्रकृयाको जटिलता वनेर आएको छ । खासगरी निरंकुताको अन्तसम्मको रोडम्याप स्पष्ट भए पनि त्यसपछिको के भन्ने वारेमा स्पष्ट हुन नसक्दा यतिवेला जटिलता पैदा भएको छ ।
विस्तृत शान्ति संझौताःर सेना र हतियार सम्वन्धि संझौता
अर्को महत्वपूर्ण दस्तावेजका वारेमा चर्चा गर्दा विस्तृत शान्त्ाि संझौताका साथै सेना र हतियार सम्वन्धि संझौता अघि आउछ । यसमा पनि सेना समायोजन र पुनस्थापनाका वारेमा विसद चर्चा त गरियो तर पनि ईमान्दरिताका अभावमा र स्वार्थका कारणले त्यसको वुझाई र व्याख्यामा अन्तर आई परयो जसका कारण यसको मापदण्ड मोडालिटि संख्या र पद मिलानको वारेमा आजसम्म पनि विवाद नै कायम छ जसले शान्ति प्रकृयालाई सहज टुगोमा पुरयाउन कठिन वनाएको छ ।
अन्तरिम संविधानः
शान्ति प्रकृयाको अर्को दस्तावेज अन्तरिम संविधान हो जसमा विस्तृत शान्त संझौता र सेना र हतियार सम्वन्धि अनँुगमन र व्यवस्थापन सुंभौताका व्यवस्थाहरुलाई जस्ताको तस्तै राख्ने काम गरियो र शान्ति प्रकृयाका जटिलताहरुलाई संवैधानिकीकरण गर्ने काम त भयो तर त्यसले समाधानलाई सुझाउन भने सकेन । तै पनि हाम्रा सामु कायम रहेको संविधान र संविधानको अंग वनेका दस्तावेजहरु नै हुन समाधानका उपायहरु यी वाहेक अरु केही हुन सक्दैनन् खाली ती दस्तावेजहरुमा एकरुपमताको वुझाइ र ईमान्दारिता पूर्वक पालनाको प्रतिवद्धता अझै भनौ समाधानमुखी वुझाई र व्यख्या यसका महत्वपूर्ण पाटो हुन भन्ने नै हाम्रो व’झाई ह’न पर्दछ ।
त्यस पछि भएका अन्य संझोताहरुः
१२ वुदे देखि अन्तरिम संविकानसम्म औपचारिक संझोताहरु भए पनि त्यस पछि पनि दलहरु विचमा विभिन्न समयमा विभिन्न पक्षहरुसंग शान्ति प्रकृयाका वारेमा संझौताहरु हुने गरेका छन् ती संझोताहरुले नेपाली शान्ति प्रकृयाको स्पष्ट चित्र दिने पनि गरेको छ तर पनि ती संझोताहरुको औपचारिक हैसियत वा तिनको संवैधानिक हैसियत वा तिनले संवैधानिक हैसियतलाई काटन सक्ने क्षमताका वारेमा प्रश्न चिन्ह उठने गरेका कारणले पनि यो समस्या आई परेको हुन सक्दछ यसका अलावा पनि संवैधानिक व्यवस्थाको ईमान्दारितपूर्वक पालना र समस्याको सामुहिकिकरण र समान रुपमा जिम्मेवारी लिने कुराको अभाव अर्को समस्याका रुपमा खडा भएको छ ।
मुख्यतः नियतकै प्रश्न होः
संसदवादी दलहरु र माओवादीका वीचमा १२ वुदे सहमति गर्दा जे समझदारी भएको थियो त्यसलाई जस्ताको तस्तै पालना गरिदिएका भए वा संविधानसभाको चुनाव अघि नै सेना समायोजनकालागि तयार भैदिएका भए सायद अहिले यो समस्या आई पर्ने थिएन होला । १२ वुदे तयार गर्दै गर्दा जनमुक्ति सनाको वारेमा के हुन्छ भनेर सोधिदा शाही सेना राजाको पक्षमा लडेको र जनमुक्ति सेना मात्रै गणतन्त्रकालागि लडेको हुदा ती सवै राष्ट्रिय सेनामा समायेाजन हुन्छन भनिएको कुरा यतिवेला स्मरण गर्ने र ईमानका साथ पालना गरिदिने हो भने समस्याको गाठो नै फुक्ने थियो । फेरि संविधानसभाको निर्वाचन अगावै सोकाम गरिदिएका भए पनि समस्या यो हदको हुने थिएन त्यतिवला पनि राजा रहेसम्म क्याण्टेानमेण्टमा माओवादी सेना राख्न जरुरी छ अन्यथा राजाले संविधानसभाको च’नाव भाडने खतरा रहन्छ भनिएका कारणले तत्काल समायोजन भएन । आज ति दुवैथरी कुरा स्मरणको पनि चासो रहदैन यस खालको प्रवृत्तिले पनि समस्या वल्झाएको देखिन्छ ।
नया पहलकदमीको खाचोः
हिजो के कारणले समस्याहरु वल्झिएर रहे सो को चर्चा गरियो र तिनको चर्चा पटक पटक गर्न पर्दछ तर अव समाधानकालागि नया पकलकदमीको खाचो छ यसकालागि दुवै पक्षले एक अर्कामा सम्मान हुने गरेर वा एक अर्काको मर्म वुझने गरेर नै समाधान खोजियो भने मात्रै समाधान निकाल्न सकिन्छ अन्यथा समस्यालाई वल्झाउने वाहेक अरु केही हुनै सक्दैन । यसकालागि निम्न उपायहरु कामयावी हुन सक्दछन् ।
ड्डसवैभन्दा पहिला माओवादी सेना देश र जनताकालागि गणतन्त्र र संविधानसभाकालागि लडेको हो जो संभव तुल्याईसकेको छ । यसका साथै धर्मनिरपेक्षता संघीयता र समावेशिता पनि उसका एजेण्डाहरु हुन जुन कुरा यतिवेला संभव भैसकेका छन् त्यसकारण उ विजयी सेना हो । विजयी सेनाको सम्मान गर्न राज्यले सक्नुपर्छ । यसो गर्न राज्यले सक्ने हो भने माओवादी सेना तत्कालिन शाही सेनामा जागिर खान पद पाउन वा राहतका नाममा आकर्षक प्याकेज भन्दै सौदा गर्ने ठाउमा उभिने छैन यसकालागि उभिन सुहाउने पनि छैन । तर यो मान्यता दिन सकिएन भने उसकालागि सेनामा वा सम्वन्धित सुरक्षा निकायमा आकर्षक पद जिम्मेवारी वा सो नभए आकर्षक प्याकेज विकल्पमा आउछ । यो वास्तविकतालाई पहिला ध्यान दिन जरुरी छ ।
ड्डद्योश्रो तहमा माओवादी सेनाको व्यवसायीकरण र नेपाली सेनाको लोकतान्त्रिकरण आजको आवश्यकता हो यही आवश्यकताका आधारमा सेना समायेाजन र पुनस्थापनाको काम कारवाहीलाई अघि वढाउन पर्दछ ।यसकालागि माओवादी सेनाको सम्मानमा आच नआउने गरी उसले देश र जनताकालागि गरेको योगदानको कदर गर्दै उसले विगतमा गरेको सेवाको गणना गर्दै सोही आधारमा एकापसमा सम्मान जगाउने नै हिसावले समायोजनको कार्ययोजना वनाउ । यसकालागि समायोजन र पुनस्थापनाकालागि आवश्यक संख्या निर्धारण गरौ जो आपसी विश्वास जगाउने र माओवादी सेनाका हकमा सम्मान जाग्ने खालको नै होस । समायोजनको संख्या निर्धारण गर्दा दुवै पक्षको सख्या निर्धारण गरिराखिएको छैन भने यसमा अनावश्यक कन्जुस्या ीगर्न जरुरी छैन । माओवादी सेनाको ईच्छा र रुचिका आधारमा संख्या निर्धारण गर्नु नै वुद्धिमत्ता हुन आउछ ।
ड्डद्यर्जा मिलानका वारेमा कुरा गरिरहदा माओवादी सेना तत्कालिन शाही सेनालाई काउण्टर दिन सक्ने सेना हो । यसको हैसियत त्यसका आधारमा मापन गर्ने हो भने अव कु दर्जा दिने भन्ने कुरामा विवाद गर्न जरुरी छैन उ वरावरको हैसियत उसले कायम गरिसकेको छ । दुई समानान्तर सेनाको संवैधानिक हैसियत पनि उसले वनाईसकेको अवस्था छ । यो पहिलो तर्क हो हैन समाधानकालागि सवै लचिलो हुन पर्छ भन्ने हो भने त्यसकालागि सवैले आफना अडान छोडन पर्छ यसो गदा व्यवहारिकता र सम्मानमा आच नपुग्ने कुरालाई ख्याल राख्ने हो भने नेपाली सेनावाट प्रस्तावित मोडेल जसमा नया महानिर्देशनालय खडा गर्ने भनिएको छ त्यसको पहिलो हकदार माओवादी सेना नै हुन्छ यसमा विवाद गर्न जरुरी नै छैन । यसो गर्दा त्यहा रहने पदको पहिलो हकदार माओवादीलाई वनाउदै अरु पदहरुमा अनुपातिक ढंगले मिलान गर्न सकिन्छ । यसो भयो भने विवाद समाधान गर्न सकिन्छ ।
ड्डम्ापदण्डको कुरा गरिरहदा सेना सेना नै हो लुला लंगडाहरुको सेना वनाइएको छैन त्यसैले शारिरिक तन्दुरुस्ती नै उसको मापदण्ड हो यसलाई सवैले स्वीकार गर्ने कुरा समाधानमुखी हुनेछ । यो वाहेक अरु वहाना खोजियो भने समाधान नचाहने मनसाय नै झल्कने छ । त्यसो त नेपाली सेनाको प्रवक्ता व्हील चेयरमा हिडने र जर्नेलको पदमा पनि आसिन हुने कुराले मापदण्डमा लचिलो हुन सवैलाई प्रेरित गर्दछ । यति कुरा मात्रै ख्याल गर्ने हो भने युद्धका वखत आफनो अंग भंग भएका र अस्वस्थहरुकालागि पनि सेनामा स्थान सुरक्षित छ भन्ने कुरा नै प्रमाणित गर्दछ तथापि सेना सेना नै हो भन्ने कुरा आत्मसात गर्ने हो भने यो हदसम्म पनि जान जरुरी छैन खालि कुरा यति हो युद्धमा अंगभंग भएकाहरुलाई पनि राज्यले सम्मान नै गर्छ भन्ने सन्देश भने दिन जरुरी छ र सकिन्छ ।
ड्डपुनस्थापनाको सवाल केवल पैसाको सवाल हैन राज्यले दिने सम्मानको सावल पनि हो । एक पटक मन्त्री भएका मानिसहरु पि एस ओ लिएर हिडन मिल्छ एक पटक गृहमन्त्री भएकाहरु ऋगुवा र पछुवा लिएर हिडन मिल्छ भने एक पटक युद्ध लडेकाहरुकालागि केही व्यवस्थ ागर्न किन मिल्दैन यसरी हेर्दा पुनस्थापनाको वहुआयामीक प्याकेज तयार गर्न मार्ग प्रसस्त गर्दछ ।
ड्डमुख्य कुरा सत्ता हो सत्तामा भागवण्डा मिलेका दिनमा समस्यालाई हेनेृ एकै प्रकारको दृउष्टकोण वन्ने छ । एकै विषयमा दृष्टिकोण अलग अलग वन्यो भने पनि त्यो सत्तामा साझेदारी नमिलेका कारणले वनेको हो भन्ने कुरा स्पष्ट हुन आएको छ । त्यसैले मुलुकका समस्याहरुलाई पनि सत्ताको स्वार्थसंग दाजेर हेर्ने प्रचलन समाधान मुखी प्रचलन र व्यवहार पटक्कै हैन वरु समस्यामा सत्तामोह प्रदर्शन गर्ने प्रचलन हो । आन्तरिक वा वाह्य जहासुकै भए पनि आफनो स्वार्थ पूर्ति गर्ने साधनका रुपमा जनमुक्ति सेनालाई प्रयोग गर्ने उसलाई सिरानी हाल्ने र उसलाई भरयाड वनाएर कुसर्ी प्राप्त गर्ने खेल सोभनीय खेल पनि हैन र यो धेरै टिक्ने खेल पनि हैन तसर्थ यस तर्फ सवै गंभिर वन्न जरुरी छ ।
समाधानको विकल्प नै छैनः
शान्ति प्रकृया हाम्रो आफनै प्रकृया हो यसलाई समाधानमा पुरयाउनु वाहेक अर्को कुनै विकल्प हामीसंग छैन । यसलाई समाधान गर्न सकिएन भने यसको परिणाम धेरै नराम्रो हुनेछ । खासगरी जनमुक्ति सेनाको धैर्यता सधैभर कायम रहने छैन । उसलाई भरयाड वनाएर पद प्राप्त गरेको पनि उसले वुझेको छ र पद प्राप्त गर्नकालागि उसलाई तेस्र्याउने र उसका पक्षमा गोहीका आसु झार्ने गरेको पनि उसले वुझेको छ । उसको विवशतामा आफनो हित देख्ने प्रवृत्ति विल्कुल हितकर छैन । वेलैमा यस वारेमा सचेत वनौ अन्यथा हातमा हतियार भएको र हतियार चलाउन जानेको जनशक्ति विश्रृखलित हुनॆ अवस्थामा पुग्दा यसको परिणाम गंभिर हुने छ । त्यसैले त्यो गंभिरतालाई आमन्त्रण गर्नुभन्दा समाधानकालागि तयार वनौं । शान्ति र संविधानवाट संवृद्ध वन्दै अघि न
राष्ट्रिय सहमति र यसका आधारहरु
नेपाली राजनीतिमा सवैभन्दा वढी भनिएको तर नगरिएको शव्द सहमति यतिवेला फेरि चर्चामा छ । त्यसोत १२ वुदे सहमति देखि संविधानसभाको निर्वाचनसम्म सम्पन्न गर्दा सहमति कायम भएको पनि हो जसको परिणाम शाही कदमलाई परास्त गर्न जनआन्दोलन सम्पन्न गर्नअन्तरिम संविधान जारी गर्न संविधानसभाको निर्वाचन गर्न संभव भएको थियो निर्वाचन पछिको पहिलो वैठक जो गणतन्त्र घोषणा गर्न समर्थ भएको थियो यतिवेलासम्म नेपाली समाजमा खुशीको संचार छाएको थियो । तर गणतन्त्रको घोषणा पश्चात राष्ट्रपतिको व्यवस्थाका वारेमा कुरा नल्दिा पुरै राजनीतिमा गत्यारेाध आईपुग्यो । सविधानमा निकै छलफल र वुद्धिमत्तापुर्ण तरिकाले अपनाईएको सहमतिय मोडेललाई भत्काएर वहुमतीय मोडेलमा जाने कुरा सत्तापक्ष र विपक्षको अवधारणा ल्याउने कुराको प्रत्यक्ष असर शान्ति र संविधानमा परयो आर्थिक सामाजिक रुपान्तरणको कुरा त धेरै टाढाको कुरा वन्न पुग्यो नेपाली राजनीतिको गहिरो धक्का यही वन्न पुग्यो । सत्ता पक्ष र विपक्षमा विभाजित राजनीतिले शान्ति संविधान र आर्थिक विकास जस्ता विषय असंभव प्राय नै थिए अहिले नेपाली धर्ति त्यसैको पिडा वोध गरि राखेको छ । संविधानसभाको निर्वाचन पछिको पहिलो गणतान्त्रिक सरकारको प्रधानमन्त्री प्रचण्ड वन्नुभो नेपाली कंग्रेस वाहेकको प्राय सवैको सहमति थियो लगभग असी प्रतिशतको समर्थनमा वनेको सरकार लगभग आफनै आन्तरिक कारण प्रधान वनेर ढल्न पुग्यो । राष्ट्रपतिको असंवैधानिक कदमका जगमा वनेको माधव नेपालको सरकार पनि पुरै असफल वनेर ढल्यो सहमतिको माला जप्दै वनेको सरकार झन सहमति कायम गर्नमा असफल वनेर आफनै पार्टी र अफनै गठवन्धन सहयात्रीको सहमति जुटाउन असफल भएर आफै राजिनामाको दिन तोकेर आफनो सरकारको दिन गनिराखेको छ । संविधान निर्माणको असी प्रतिशत काम सम्पन्न गर्न सफल प्रचण्ड सरकारले छाडेका वांकी विस प्रतिशत कामकालागि त्यस पछिका सरकार पुरै असफल रहे भने त्यही वाकी काम सम्पन्न गर्नकालागि सहमतिको सरकार फेरि पनि चाहिएको छ त्यही सहमतिको सरकारको थेगो अहिले पनि वनिराखेको छ ।
राजतन्त्रको अन्त पछि सामन्तवादका अवशेषहरुलाई प्रमुख दुश्मनमा चित्त नवुझाएर नेपाली कांग्रेसलाई त्यो स्थानमा देख्न शास्त्रिीय कम्युनिष्टको एकथरी सोच र परम्परागत आफनो सत्ता खोसिएको नमिठो अनुभूतिकासाथ रन्थनिएको नेपाली कांग्रेस चुनावको परिणामलाई आत्मसात गर्न नसक्ने अवस्थामा पुग्नु र माओवादीलाई प्राप्त जनमतलाई ठाडै अस्वीकार गर्नु नेपाली राजनीतिका ऐजेरुहरु रहे जसका कारण यतिका लामो अवधिसम्म न शान्ति न संविधान न आर्थिक सामाजिक रुपान्त्रणका सवालहरुले मुर्त रुप प्राप्त गर्न सके वरु दश वर्षको जनयुद्ध र जनआन्दोलनवाट प्राप्त उपलव्धी गुमाउने नै हदसम्म दलहरु लागि परेको त्यसको रक्षाकालागि दलहरुले योजना नवनाएको यथार्थ यतिवेला हाम्रा सामु विद्यामान छ ।
ज्ानयुद्धका उपलव्धीको रक्षाकालागि सहमतिः
गणतन्त्र जनयुद्धको महत्वपुर्ण उपलव्धी हो । राजतन्त्र र सामन्तवादका जराहरु गाउ गाउवाट उखल्ने काम जनयुद्धका दौरानमा भएको थियो । तत्कालिन सात दलसंगको सहकार्य सहितको जनआन्दोलन यसको परिणाम थियो । तर राजतन्त्रका जराहरु पूर्णतया समाप्त भैसकेका छैनन् र एक पटक समाप्त भैसकेको राजतन्त्रले पुन स्थापित हुने अवसर खोजिराखेको अवस्था पनि छ यसका साथसाथै निकै लामो संघर्षका साथ प्राप्त गणतन्त्रलाई नया संविधान मार्फत संस्थागत गर्ने कुरा अर्को जिम्मेवारी पनि हो । नया संविधान नवनाईकन राजतन्त्र अन्त भएर प्राप्त गणतन्त्र संस्थागत हुने अवस्थामा छैन । तसर्थ यस प्रयोजनकालागि सहमति आजको आवश्यकता हो ।
सविधमासभाको रक्षँँ र सफलताकालागि सहमतिः
संविधानसभा सहजै प्राप्त भएको विषय हैन । विगत ६१ व्र्षदेखिको माग वल्ल वल्ल पुरा भएको अवस्था हो । संविधानसभा संभव तुल्याउन माओवादी जनयुद्ध मुख्य रुपमा जिम्मेवार छ । यसको अभावमा असंभव प्राय थियो । संविधानसभाका लागि मात्रै हजारौ योद्धाहरुको शहादत भएको हो । कैयन वेपत्ता छन् कैयन वन्दी घाईते र जोखिमपुर्ण जीवन विताउन वाध्य छन् यस्तो महंगो र क्षतिपूर्ति गर्न असंभव योगदानवाट मात्रै प्राप्त भएको हो संविधान सभा तसर्थ जो यो योगदानलाई स्वीकार गर्न चाहदैनन् उनीहरु संविधानसभा चाहदैनथे र नचाहदानचाहदै प्राप्त भएको संविधानसभा सफल भएको देख्न चाहेका छैनन् तसर्थ यस्तो जोखिममा रहेको संविधानसभालाई कुनै पनि मुल्यमा जोगाउनु यतिवलाको आवश्यकता हो । यसकालागि सहमति अनिवार्य छ । कामसेकम संविधानसभाका पक्षधरहरु यसलाई जोगाउने मामलामा सहमत हुन जरुरी छ ।
ज्ानताको संविधानकालागि सहमित
इतिलेलाको संविधानसभाको संरचनाले जनवादी संविधान पनि हैन र विगतको संविधानको निरन्तरता पनि हैन । दुवैको वीचवाट कमसेकम प्रगतिशिल आर्थिक सामाजिक रुपान्तरणलाई सहज वनाउने खालको संविधान वन्न संभव छ । तर यही संविधान वनाउनकालागि पनि सहमतिको खाचो छ कसैले पनि आफैले चाहेजस्तो संविधान वनाउन पर्याप्त मत पाएका छैनन् सवैको सहकार्यमा जनताको जीवनस्तर उकास्न सकने र जनताको सामाजिक सुरक्षा र लोककल्याणकारी व्यवस्थ ागने खालको संविधान यतिवेलाको खाचो हो यो व्यवस्थाकालागि पनि सहमति जरुरी छ । जसलाई जनताको संविधान हामीले भनेका छौ त्यसकालागि हाम्रा मात्रै मतले पुग्दैन संविधान वनाउन चाहिने मत दुईतिहाई हामीले जुटाउनै पर्दछ यसकालागि पनि सहमतिको खाचो छ । फेरि सहमति के आधारमा पनि आवश्यक छ भने हामी जनवादी संविधान वनाउन हिडेकाहरु प्नि र पुरानै राजतन्त्रवादी संविधान जोगाउन वसेकाहरु प्नि दुवैथरी संझौतामा आएका हुन । यो संझौताको मर्म र जनताको जनादेश यतिवेलाका सहमतिका आधार वन्न पर्छ यसो भएमा सहमतिय सहकार्य फलिभुत हुने छ ।
शान्तिकालागि सहमतिः
नेपाली जनता भिषण युद्धमा थिए आफनो अधिकारको प्राप्तीकालगि भनेर मान्ने हो भने माओवादी जनयुद्ध भिन्न प्रकारको युद्धको निरन्तरता नै थियो । यस अघि पनि नेपाली जनताले आफना दुश्मनका विरुद्ध वेला वखतमा नलडेका हैनन् । यी सवै लडाईहरु दिर्घकालिन शान्तिका लािग थिए । यदि हामी त्यो मिशनमा प्रतिवद्ध छौ भने युद्धका वदत खडा गरिएको सैन्य संरचनाको विघटन हैनकि त्यसको स्वरुपमा परिवर्तनको खाचो हो । जनमुक्ति सेनालाई गुरिल्ला युद्धको अनुभव संगसंगै नियमित सेनाको अनुभव वाट लैस वनाउदै व्यवसायीकरण गर्दै राष्ट्र हितका पक्षमा अुभै जुझारु व्ानाउने र शाही सेना अहिले नेपाली सेनामा वदलिएको छ त्यसलाई लोकतान्त्रिकरण गरेर नया राष्ट्रिय सेनाको निर्माण गर्ने कुरा नै यतिवेलाको कार्यभार हो । यसकालागि पनि सहमति जरुरी छ । राष्ट्रिय सहमति विना यो काम पूरा गर्न सकिन्न भन्ने कुरा विगतका वहुमतीय सरकारका कार्यकाल साछी छन् ।
जनताको आर्थिक विकासकालागि सहमतिः
आधारभूत जनताको आर्थिक सामाजिक रुपान्तरण जनयुद्ध र जनआन्दोलन सवैको धेय थियो । यसको मतलव यस अघिका शासन व्यवस्था र आर्थिक व्यवस्थापनहरु ज्नहितकारी थिएनन् त्यसैकारणले जनताको आर्थिक विकासमा तिनले ध्यान दिन सकेनन् भन्ने नै यतिवेलाको निष्कर्ष हो । जव राजनैतिक परिवर्तन उपरिसंरचना मात्रै हो र यसको आधार भनेको आर्थिक सम्वन्ध हो भनेर हामी मान्दछौ भने र आर्थिक आधार विना उपरिसंरचना टिक्न सक्दैनौ भन्ने कुरालाई मान्दछौ भने आर्थिक सामाजिक रुपान्तरणको यो मामलामा हामी गंभिर हुनै पर्छ हामीले प्राप्त गरेको राजनैतिक उपलव्धीको रक्षाका खातिर पनि आर्थिक विकास जरुरी छ भन्ने कुरामा हामी सहमत हुनै पर्दछ र जनताको आर्थिक सामाजिक विकासकालागि सहमत हुन जरुरी छ ।
राष्ट्रिय एकताका निम्ती सहमतिः
ह्ाम्रा मनहरु प्ाुटेका छन् हामी विभाजित भएका छौ र यो मन फाटाई अझै लम्विदै जाने हो भने यसले विखण्डनको रुप नलेला भन्न पनि सकिदैन । तसर्थ यस संवेदनशिल घडीमा हामीले हाम्रा सोचाईहरुलाई फराकिलो वनाउदै हाम्रा चिन्तनहरुलाई व्यवहारमा विशाल वनाउदै सवैका भावनाहरुलाई समेटदै राष्ट्रिय एकताको भावनाको जागृत गदै अगाडि वडन जरुरी छ यो अवस्था सहमित विना संभव छैन । विविधतायुक्त नेपाली समाजको मर्मलाई वोध गर्दै सवैको पहिचान र अधिकारलाई सुनिश्चित गर्दै सवै वर्ग समुदायलाई अधिकारसम्पन्न वनाउदै राष्ट्रिय एकताको प्रवर्धन गर्न सकिने यथार्थलाई आत्मसात गर्दै राष्ट्रिय एकता वनाई राख्ने आजको आवश्यकता हो यसकालागि पनि सहमतिको खाचो छ ।
ज्नताको आत्मवल वढाउन पनि सहमतिः
इतिवेला नेपाली जनतामा राजनैतिक दल र पार्टीहरु प्रति नकारात्मक धारणाको विकास भएको छ । नेताहरु खालि कुसर्ीकालागि मन्त्री वन्नकालागि झगडा गर्छन भन्ने कुरा सवैले देख्ने गरी स्थापित भएको । दलहरु देश र जनताका एजेण्डाहरुप्रति वेखवर रहेको पद प्राप्ती र सुविधाको खोजिमा भौतारिएको जस्ता आरोपहरु ऋव सत्य ठहरिन थालेका छन् । शान्ति संविधान जनताको आर्थिक विकास जस्ता विषयहरु अव त सुनिन पनि छाडि सके । यस्तो अवस्थामा दल र नेताहरुलाई दवता नै मान्ने आम जनता यतिवेला निराश छन् । जनताको यो निराशा देशको उन्नतिको हिसावले पटक्कै राम्रो लक्षण होईन । यसकारण जनताको यो मनोभावनालाई वदल्न जनतालाई निराशावाट मुक्त गर्न पनि माथि उल्लेखित ऐजेण्डा केन्द्रित पद केन्द्रित होईन सहमतिको खाचो छ त्यसकालागि माथिका एजेण्डामा प्रतिवद्ध नेताको नेतृत्वमा सहमतिको सरकार वनाउन र देश र जनताका वांकी कार्यभार पूरा गर्न जरुरी छ । यसकालागि राष्ट्रिय सहमति एकमात्रै विकल्प हो । परिणाममुखी राष्ट्रिय सहमतिको आधार तयार पार्दै सोही आधारमा राष्ट्रिय सहमतिको सरकार निर्माण गरौ र शान्ति संविधान र आर्थिक विकास जस्ता ऐजेण्डा पूरा गरौं यसैमा देश जनता दल नेता र कार्यकर्ताको हित छ फगत पद र कुसर्ीको मोहले यो कुरा संभव छैन ।
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
-
SECURITY SECTOR REFORM Democratization of Nepal Army By Hari Krishna Devkota Submitted to Nepal Transitio...
-
1 Single and open fact: Medical debt is an especially notable phenomenon in the United states the US being the world's only develope...
